Acceptance test-driven development

ATDD is closely related to test-driven development (TDD). It differs by the emphasis on developer-tester-business customer collaboration. ATDD encompasses acceptance testing, but highlights writing acceptance tests before starting any coding.

Overview

Acceptance tests are from the user's point of view – the external view of the system. They examine externally visible effects, such as specifying the correct output of a system given a particular input. Acceptance tests can verify how the state of something changes, such as an order that goes from "paid" to "shipped". They also can check the interactions with interfaces of other systems, such as shared databases or web services. In general, they are implementation independent, although automation of them may not be.

Creation

Acceptance tests are created when the requirements are analyzed and prior to coding. They can be developed collaboratively by requirement requester (product owner, business analyst, customer representative, etc.), developer, and tester. Developers implement the system using the acceptance tests. Failing tests provide quick feedback that the requirements are not being met. The tests are specified in business domain terms. The terms then form a ubiquitous language that is shared between the customers, developers, and testers. Tests and requirements are interrelated. A requirement that lacks a test may not be implemented properly. A test that does not refer to a requirement is an unneeded test. An acceptance test that is developed after implementation begins represents a new requirement.

Testing strategy

Acceptance tests are a part of an overall testing strategy. They are the customer/user oriented tests that demonstrate the business intent of a system. Depending on your test strategy, you may use them in combination with other test types, e.g. lower level Unit tests, Cross-functional testing including usability testing, exploratory testing, and property testing (scaling and security).

One more chapter is free with a Lably account.

Acceptance criteria and tests

Acceptance criteria are a description of what would be checked by a test. Given a requirement such as "As a user, I want to check out a book from the library", an acceptance criterion might be, "verify the book is marked as checked out". An acceptance test for this requirement gives the details so that the test can be run with the same effect each time.

Test format

Acceptance tests usually follow this form:

Given (setup)

A specified state of a system

When (trigger)

An action or event occurs

Then (verification)

The state of the system has changed or an output has been produced

Also, it is possible to add Statements that start with AND in any of the sections below (Given, When, Then).

For the example requirement, the steps could be listed as:

<span id="mwdw"></span><span class="k" id="mweA">Given </span><span class="nf" id="mweQ">Book that has not been checked out</span> <span class="k" id="mweg">And </span><span class="nf" id="mwew">User who is registered on the system</span> <span class="k" id="mwfA">When </span><span class="nf" id="mwfQ">User checks out a book</span> <span class="k" id="mwfg">Then </span><span class="nf" id="mwfw">Book is marked as checked out</span>

Complete test

The previous steps do not include any specific example data, so that is added to complete the test:

Given:

Book that has not been checked out

User who is registered on the system

When:

User checks out a book

Then:

Book is marked as checked out

Test examination

Examination of the test with specific data usually leads to many questions. For the sample, these might be:

What if the book is already checked out?
What if the book does not exist?
What if the user is not registered on the system?
Is there a date that the book is due to be checked-in?
How many books can a user check out?

These questions help illuminate missing or ambiguous requirements. Additional details such as a due-date can be added to the expected result. Other acceptance tests can check that conditions such as attempting to check out a book that is already checked out produces the expected error.

Another test example

Suppose the business customer wanted a business rule that a user could only check out one book at a time. The following test would demonstrate that:

Scenario: Check that checkout business rule is enforced

Given:

Book that has been checked out

When:

User checks out another book