Elvira Roca Barea

Awards

In 2018 she was awarded the Medal of Andalusia and Medal of Honor of San Telmo awarded by the Andalusian government.

In 2019, Roca-Barea's "Imperiophobia and Leyenda Negra" won the Espasa-Calpe Award for works of literature, journalism and thought, awarded annually since 1984. According to the jury her work was "a magnificent essay, a brave revision which changes the traditional image of the history of Spain and the understanding that we Spaniards have of ourselves."

Reception

Ricardo García Cárcel, Chair of Early Modern History at the Autonomous University of Barcelona and author of La leyenda negra: historia y opinión (1992), argues that, whether Roca Barea likes it or not, it is not currently possible to find any European or American historian with scientific credentials who accepts the extremes of the so-called Leyenda negra ("Black Legend"). This, according to Carcel, is precisely because the exaggerations of the Black Legend have already been thoroughly deconstructed by European and American hispanists such as Elliott, Parker, Benassar or Vincent.

The historian Fernando García de Cortázar, Professor of Contemporary History at the University of Deusto and director of the Vocento Foundation and National History Prize 2008, believes that with Elvira Roca's work "we are once again aware of to what extent the entire history of Spain was misrepresented and had been manipulated to offer an absolutely negative view of it and, of course, contrary to the progress of civilization."

Historian Miguel Martínez, of the University of Chicago, finds fault with her presentation of empires as "victims" instead of aggressors. In his review of Roca's Imperiofobia he states that while it is well-sourced it also contains key historical omissions and severe ideological bias. Martínez argues that Roca systematically omits relevant data contradicting her vision of the Spanish Empire, giving examples such as Roca Barea's comparison of a supposed lack of rebellions in the Spanish Americas with the Indian Mutiny when in reality there were dozens of rebellions against Spanish rule. He also highlights Roca Barea's dismissal of Spanish atrocities in the Americas, citing exceptionally well-documented practices such as amputation, burning and mass killings. He further criticises Roca Barea's refusal to engage with the role of England as an imperial power, arguing that "exploring anti-British propaganda would have rendered her dated vision of perfidious Albion as a machine of anti-Hispanic propaganda absurd". He also takes issue with various perceived inconsistencies between the way she applies her arguments to the history of Spain and to that of other countries. In his view "with numerous scraps of truth, Roca Barea weaves a monumental fallacy which is intellectually unsustainable and dangerous from an ethical and political point of view".

José Luis Villacañas authored Imperiofilia y el populismo nacional-católico (Lengua de Trapo, 2019), as a refutation of Imperiofobia. According to Villacañas, Imperiofobia lacks intellectual rigour and is alien to the parametres of "historical and academic research", featuring a brand of "reactionary intellectual populism". Villacañas considers the underlying interest in the work of Barea to be the underpinning of an ancient metaphysical struggle between Catholicism (identified by Barea with "Spain") and protestantism (with Barea adopting an anglophobic, germanophobic, dutchphobic vision of history, albeit, rooted in an innovative vision of "Hispanidad", rather than the historically more common Anti-US sentiment).

Regarding Fracasología, José-Carlos Mainer considers the Roca Barea's work to be blind to the wholesale reanalysis of the literary historiography dealing with the century of Enlightenment that has taken place in the last six decades, as Roca Barea does "not give a damn about all that historians and philologists have written about the 18th-century in Spain". When it comes to literary style, Mainer describes the prose in Fracasología as "capricious and impulsive", sprinkled with an "abundant" yet "arbitrary" bibliography with a number of mistakes.

She received significant praise from Peruvian Nobel Prize Winner, Mario Vargas Llosa, who considered Imperiofobia a "book of rigorous scholarship" which is "combative, deep, controversial and reads without pause".

Political positions

In 2018, Roca Barea signed a manifesto entitled Manifiesto por la historia y la libertad promoted by the Francisco Franco National Foundation, rejecting the Law of Historical Memory as "an attack on constitutional rights to political opinion and an attempt to impose an official version of history". Roca Barea is an opponent of Catalan nationalism, which she believes to be incapable of moderation, and viewed the movement which led to the Catalan independence referendum of 2017 as a "rebellion of feudal elites".