Criminal psychology

Profiling

Criminal profiling, also known as offender profiling, is a form of criminal investigation, linking an offender's actions at the crime scene to possible characteristics. This is a practice that lies between the professions of criminology, forensic science and behavioral science. Most commonly used for homicide and sexual cases, criminal profiling helps law enforcement investigators narrow down and prioritize a pool of suspects. Part of a sub-field of forensic psychology called investigative psychology, criminal profiling has advanced substantially in methodology and grown in popularity since its conception in the late 1800s.

Profiling can be helpful when investigators have limited leads and need to narrow down possible suspects. It is most effective when combined with forensic evidence, interviews, and other investigative methods.

However, there is a substantial lack of empirical research and effectiveness evaluations validating the practice of criminal profiling. Due to the lack of empirical research, it is important that criminal profiling is used as a tool in investigative cases. Cases should not depend on solely the profile but as well as traditional techniques as well.

Criminal/offender profiling is a process now known in the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) as criminal investigative analysis. (see also: FBI method of profiling) Profilers, or criminal investigative analysts, are trained and experienced law enforcement officers who study every behavioral aspect and detail of an unsolved violent crime scene, in which a certain amount of psychopathology has been left at the scene. The characteristics of a good profiler are discussed. Five behavioral characteristics that can be gleaned from the crime scene are described:

1. amount of premeditation,
2. degree of control used by the offender,
3. escalation of emotion at the scene,
4. risk level of both the offender and victim, and
5. appearance of the crime scene (disorganized versus organized).

The process of interpreting the behavior observed at a crime scene is briefly discussed.

In a 2017 article by Pew Research Center, it was found that federal and state prisons in the United States held 475,900 inmates who were African American and 436,500 who were white. Similar historical data supports the substantially higher incarceration of African American people. This is in contrast with census data which has placed the percentage of African American people at about 12% of the US population. Negative ethnic stereotypes contribute to this disproportionate incarceration; it has served as a justification for the unofficial policies and practices of racial profiling by criminal justice practitioners.

The cultural, environmental and traditional concepts of communities play a major role in individual psychology, providing profilers with a potential basis for behavioral patterns learned by offenders during their upbringing. They also evaluate the safety of prisons for those incarcerated, as some individuals may be predisposed to recidivism if the prisoners' mental health is not adequately addressed. There are several individual factors contributing to developing a criminal profile that both meets legal requirements and treats individuals humanely.

Comparison to forensics

The effect of psychosocial factors on brain functioning and behavior is a central part of analysis for both forensic and criminal psychologists, under the category of applied psychology. For forensic psychiatry, major areas of criminal evaluations include assessing the ability of an individual to stand trial, providing an opinion on what the mental state of the individual was at the time of offense, risk management for future offenses (recidivism), providing treatment to criminals including medication and psychotherapy, and being an expert witness. This process often involves psychological testing. Forensic psychologists have similar roles to forensic psychiatrists, although are unable to prescribe medication. Criminal psychologists focus on research, profiling, and educating/assisting law enforcement with the detainment of suspects.

Both criminal and forensic psychology contribute to the legal system but they do so in different ways. Their shared goal is to provide psychological insight that supports fair evaluations, informed decisions, and public safety.

Criminal and forensic psychologists may also consider the following factors:

1. The current presence of mental disorders and disabilities
2. The level of accountability or responsibility an individual has for a crime due to mental disorders
3. Likelihood of recidivism and involved risk factors
4. Epidemiology of related mental disorders under consideration
5. The motivation behind why a crime was committed.

Criminal psychology is also related to legal psychology, forensic psychology and crime investigations.

The question of competency to stand trial is to question of an offender's current state of mind. This assesses the offender's ability to understand the charges against them, the possible outcomes of being convicted/acquitted of these charges and their ability to assist their attorney with their defense. The question of sanity/insanity or criminal responsibility is an assessment of the offender's state of mind at the time of the crime. This refers to their ability to understand right from wrong and what is illegal. The insanity defense is rarely used, as it is very difficult to prove. If declared insane, an offender may be committed to a secure hospital facility, potentially for much longer than they would have served in prison.

Criminal Psychology in Practice

In practical settings, criminal psychologists are involved in criminal profiling, where behavioral patterns and psychological traits are used to help identify suspects. They also perform court-ordered psychological evaluations to determine competency, assess risk, and offer insights into an offender's mental state at the time of a crime. They may also assist correctional facilities by evaluating inmates and recommending appropriate treatment or rehabilitation programs. These evaluations can influence sentencing and treatment recommendations.

Crime Prevention

There are several programs that attempt to help teens and young adults that are having disciplinary problems and involvement with the law. These programs include Scared Straight, Boot Camps, and rehabilitation. Research shows that these programs are ineffective or that they may even increase the likelihood of participants reoffending. In order for these interventions to be effective the person needs to voluntarily accept treatment. Research has shown that the most effective methods for preventing recidivism are Cognitive Behavior Therapy (CBT) or rehabilitation programs that teach skills necessary to continue living after the duration of the programs. It is one of the most widely used methods, focusing on identifying and changing the thought patterns that lead to criminal behavior. CBT helps offenders understand the consequences of their actions and learn alternative coping strategies. Studies have shown that CBT can significantly reduce the likelihood of reoffending, particularly in young offenders. There are several therapies that are used to help criminals:

• Intensive Multimodal Cognitive Therapy
• Anger Management
• Motivational Interviewing
• Dialectical Behavior Therapy
• Schema Modal Therapy
• Functional Family Therapy
• Group-Based Cognitive Behavioral Therapy
• Mentorship Programs
• Multidimensional Family Therapy

Another approach, psychodynamic therapy, draws from Freud's psychoanalytic theory and seeks to uncover unconscious conflicts that may lead to criminal behavior. While psychodynamic therapy is less commonly used today, it can still provide valuable insights into deep-rooted psychological issues that may contribute to criminal tendencies. Additionally, anger management programs and social skills training have been implemented in various correctional settings, aiming to help offenders deal with emotions in a constructive way. These therapies are especially relevant for individuals who commit crimes due to impulse control issues or aggression.

Distinction from Forensic Psychology

Although often used interchangeably, criminal psychology and forensic psychology differ in scope. Forensic psychology broadly involves the application of psychological knowledge to legal matters, including civil and family law. Criminal psychology, by contrast, focuses specifically on understanding criminal behavior and applying this understanding in investigative and correctional settings (Gudjonsson, 2003; Bartol & Bartol, 2021).

The goal of these therapies is to help violent offenders cope and avoid committing crimes after being released. Research on in-patient therapy methods showed to not help criminals. There are risk management tools that are used to assess criminals or people who are becoming involved with the law. There is evidence that these tools help with violence and crime, but health professionals have mixed reviews on if they are effective. Research supports that Multisystemic Therapy did not have an effect on preventing crime or reoffending in juveniles. Understanding this distinction is important because the two fields are often confused. While they overlap in some areas, each field has its own focus, methods, and professional roles.

Different types of mental disorders within the system

The criminal justice system has a wide variety of people that are incarcerated, some of these people have mental illness or disabilities. Some people that are in the system come from lower socioeconomic status and have childhood trauma that later results in mental illness, such as Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), and this increases the likelihood of them being involved with the law at a young age.

Fetal Alcohol Syndrome is caused by a pregnant mother consuming alcohol. This can cause the individual to have issues with decision-making, substance abuse, and the ability to function. They are more likely to commit crimes around the age of 12, which can include drug offenses, shoplifting, and sex crimes.

Some people with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) are incarcerated, but not more than a non-autistic person. There is a difference though between gender and age. Male teenagers are more likely to have altercations with the law. When the altercations do occur they most often include crime related to stalking, drugs, theft/property damage. Ethnic lower-class women are more likely to be underdiagnosed. The increase chance of criminal behavior may be traced back to unmet needs not known.

Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) is another mental illness that inmates may have, and this can be co-morbid with other disorders, such as depression, anxiety, substance use and personality disorders. The most common co-morbid disorders among criminals is depression and substance use disorder. The inmates with PTSD are most likely to be violent with other inmates and commit more violent crimes.

Attention-Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) is another disorder that criminals are likely to have. This disorder can also be co-morbid with disorders like conduct disorder and later on can develop into antisocial personality disorder. People with ADHD often commit crimes such as assault, sex crimes, homicide, and drug charges. After being released from jail/prison people with ADHD are more likely to reoffend quicker than inmates that do not have ADHD.

Emerging Areas in Criminal Psychology

As crime continues to evolve, so too does the field of criminal psychology. With the rise of cybercrime, criminal psychologists are increasingly called upon to understand the psychological profiles of online offenders, such as hackers or individuals engaged in cyberbullying. The anonymity provided by the internet can lead to unique psychological motivations and behaviors that traditional criminological theories may not fully address.

Additionally, neuropsychology is an emerging area that explores how brain injuries, developmental disorders, or neurological conditions can influence criminal behavior. Advances in brain imaging and neuroscience are helping researchers better understand the biological factors that may contribute to criminal actions.

Career paths

A bachelor's degree in psychology or criminal justice as well as a master's degree in a related field are needed in order to pursue a career in criminal psychology. A doctorate, either a Ph.D. or a Psy.D, typically yields higher pay and more lucrative job opportunities. In addition to degrees, a licensing exam is required by state or jurisdiction.

Criminal profilers require a master's degree or a doctorate, several years of experience and in some cases passing state examinations to become a licensed psychologist.

Criminal profilers can work in various settings including offices and courtrooms and can be employed at a number of institutions. Some include local, state, or federal government, and others can be self-employed as independent consultants. As of 2021, the average amount of a criminal psychologist is $58,246 and can increase to $95,000. Several factors contribute to how much a person makes within the field, including how much time a person has worked within the field, and the city with which a person works in. Criminal psychologists who work within larger cities tend to make more than psychologists who work in lower populated cities. Those who work for hospitals or federal government tend to have a lower salary. Some of the top paying states for forensic psychologists are New Hampshire, Washington, New York, Massachusetts, and California.

Forensic psychology careers include:

1. Correctional counselor
2. Jail supervisor
3. Victim advocate
4. Jury consultant
5. Forensic social worker
6. Expert witness
7. Forensic psychology professor
8. Forensic psychology researcher
9. Forensic case manager
10. Criminal profiler
11. Forensic psychologist
12. Correctional psychologist

Key studies

A number of key studies of psychology especially relevant to understanding criminal psychology have been undertaken. These include:

• Bobo doll experiment (Bandura, Ross & Ross 1961)
• The Stanford prison experiment (Philip Zimbardo 1973)
• Eyewitness study (Loftus, Palmer 1974)

These studies remain important because they helped shape modern ideas about aggression, behavior, and memory. Their findings continue to influence criminal investigations, courtroom procedures, and psychological research.