Iberian Romance languages

Common traits between Portuguese, Spanish and Catalan

This list points to common traits of these Iberian subsets, especially when compared to the other Romance languages in general. Thus, changes such as Catalan vuit/huit and Portuguese oito vs. Spanish ocho are not shown here, as the change -it- > -ch- is exclusive to Spanish among the Iberian Romance languages.

Between Portuguese, Spanish and Catalan

Phonetic

• The length difference between r/rr is preserved through phonetic means as /, so that the second consonant in words such as caro and carro are not the same in any of the three.
• Latin U remains and is not changed to .

Semantic

• The Iberian Romance languages all maintain a complete essence-state distinction in the copula (the verb "to be"). The "essence" form (Portuguese and Spanish ser and Catalan ser and ésser) is derived in whole or in part from the Latin sum (the Latin copula), while the "state" form (estar in all three languages) is derived from the Latin stāre ("to stand").

Between Spanish and Catalan, but not Portuguese

Phonetic

• The distinction between Latin short -n-, -l- and long -nn-, -ll- was preserved by means of palatalizing -nn-, -ll- to , as in Latin annum > Spanish año, Catalan any vs. Latin manum > Spanish mano, Old Catalan man (modern Catalan mà). This also affects some initial L in Catalan. However, in most dialects of Spanish, original has become delateralized. Portuguese maintains the distinction, but in a different way; compare ano vs. mão.

Between Spanish and Portuguese, but not Catalan

Phonetic

• Initial Latin CL/FL/PL are palatalized further than in Standard Italian, and become indistinguishable (to CH in Portuguese and LL in Spanish).
• Final e/o remains (although its pronunciation changed in Portuguese, and some dialects drop final E).

Grammatical

• The synthetic preterite, inherited from earlier stages of Latin, remains the main past tense.

Between Portuguese and Catalan, but not Spanish

Phonetic

• Velarized L , which existed in Latin, is preserved at the end of syllables, and was later generalized to all positions in most dialects of both languages.
• Stressed Latin e/o, both open and closed, is preserved so and does not become a diphthong.

Statuses

Politically (not linguistically), there are now four major officially recognised Iberian Romance languages:

• Spanish (see names given to the Spanish language), is the national and official language of 21 countries, including Spain. Spanish is the fourth-most widely spoken language in the world, with over 570 total million speakers, and the second-most widely spoken native language. It has a number of dialects and varieties.
• Portuguese, official language in nine countries including Portugal and Brazil. After Spanish, Portuguese is the second most widely spoken Romance language in the world with over 250 million speakers, currently ranked seventh by number of native speakers. Various Portuguese dialects exist outside of the European standard spoken in Portugal.
• Catalan is the official language in Andorra and co-official in the Spanish autonomous communities of Catalonia, Balearic Islands and Valencian Community (where it is known as Valencian), and the Italian city of Alghero. It is also spoken in the French department of Pyrénées-Orientales (Northern Catalonia) without official recognition. Catalan is closely related to Occitan, with the two languages having been treated as one in studies by Occitanist linguists (such as Pierre Bec, or more recently Domergue Sumien). When not treated as one, the two languages are widely classified together as Occitano-Romance languages, a group which is itself sometimes grouped with the Gallo-Romance languages. Catalan has two main dialectal branches (Eastern and Western Catalan) and several subdialects, and is spoken by about 10 million people (ranking the seventy-fifth most spoken language in the world), mostly in five variants: Central Catalan, Northern Catalan, Northwestern Catalan, Valencian and Balearic.
• Galician, co-official in Galicia and also spoken in adjacent western parts of Asturias and Castile and León. Closely related to Portuguese, with Spanish influence. It shares the same origin as Portuguese, from the medieval Galician-Portuguese. Modern Galician is spoken by around 3.2 million people and is ranked 160th by number of speakers.

Additionally, Asturian (dialect of Asturleonese), although not an official language, is recognised by the autonomous community of Asturias. It is one of the Asturleonese dialects along with Mirandese, which in Portugal holds an official status as a minority language.

Family tree

The Iberian Romance languages are a conventional group of Romance languages. Many authors use the term in a geographical sense although they are not necessarily a phylogenetic group (the languages grouped as Iberian Romance may not all directly descend from a common ancestor). Phylogenetically, there is disagreement about what languages should be considered within the Iberian Romance group; for example, some authors consider that East Iberian, also called Occitano-Romance, could be more closely related to languages of northern Italy (or also Franco-Provençal, the langues d'oïl and Rhaeto-Romance). A common conventional geographical grouping is the following:

• East Iberian
• West Iberian

Daggers (†) indicate extinct languages

• Iberian Romance languages
  • East Iberian (alternatively classified as Occitano-Romance languages)
    • Catalanic
      • Catalan
      • Judaeo-Catalan†
    • Occitanic
      • Gardiol
      • Occitan
      • Shuadit†
  • West Iberian
    • Asturleonese
      • Asturian
      • Cantabrian
      • Extremaduran
      • Leonese
      • Mirandese
    • Castilian
      • Spanish
      • Judaeo-Spanish
    • Galician-Portuguese
      • Eonavian
      • Fala
      • Galician
      • Judaeo-Portuguese†
      • Portuguese
    • Pyrenean–Mozarabic
      • Navarro-Aragonese†
        • Aragonese
          • Valencian Aragonese†
          • Judaeo-Aragonese†
        • Navarrese†
        • Riojan†
      • Mozarabic†