Christos Tsountas

Excavations

Most of Tsountas's excavations took place in his early career, with a particular concentration between 1886 and 1908. Between 1880 and 1891, Tsountas excavated in the southern Greek region of Laconia. His excavations there included the tholos tomb at Vapheio; although the tomb had previously been cleared in 1805, Tsountas discovered an intact burial in its floor, with grave goods including the two Vapheio Cups. Tsountas was the first modern archaeologist to excavate and publish a burial in a tholos, demonstrating that the monuments were constructed as tombs and disproving the then-widespread belief that they were constructed as royal treasuries. Tsountas's campaign in Laconia also included the excavation, in 1890, of the Mycenaean shrine known as the Amyklaion. There, he discovered two sculpted heads, known as the "Amyklai Heads", which have been variously dated to the Mycenaean and the Geometric periods, and one of which may have represented the god Apollo.

From 1884, he worked on the Acropolis of Athens. In 1884, he led an underwater survey to investigate the site of the Battle of Salamis, which took place in 480 BCE; though poor weather made the enterprise largely unsuccessful, it may have been the first archaeological work to take place under water. He also excavated at the Mycenaean citadel of Tiryns in the Argolid between 1890 and 1891.

In 1887, Tsountas excavated the looted cemeteries of Tanagra in Boeotia. He worked at Tiryns in 1890–1891, and excavated the tholos tomb at Kambos near Avia in Messenia in 1891, uncovering Minoan-type figurines. Between 1890 and 1892, he assisted Kavvadias, then Ephor General, in cataloguing the prehistoric material in the National Archaeological Museum. Tsountas was made curator of the museum's Mycenaean and Egyptian collections by 1896, by which point he had also written the catalogue for its Mycenaean material.

Mycenae

Following the excavation of Grave Circle A at Mycenae under the German businessman Heinrich Schliemann and Stamatakis in 1876–1877, Tsountas took over the site from May 1886 until 1910. He made the first excavations in the Prehistoric Cemetery around the settlement of Mycenae and carried out the first major excavations of its acropolis, where he uncovered the Great Ramp, cleared the slopes of the citadel and uncovered a large proportion of its buildings. Tsountas's discovery of Ancient Egyptian material, including seven faience plaques bearing the name of the pharaoh Amenhotep III, on the acropolis gave the first definitive evidence of the site's date in the Late Bronze Age (c. 1600 – c. 1200 BCE); it had previously been dated only in vague terms, often described by travellers in terms such as "of the most ancient date", or considered to date to various periods around 1000 BCE.

The main purpose of Tsountas's initial excavations of 1886 was to discover the palatial centre of the site of Mycenae. In that year, he cleared the majority of the citadel, discovering the palace and megaron and excavating the Hellenistic temple built atop the acropolis; he would later remove the temple's remains, as well as most of those from post-Mycenaean periods, to further reveal the Bronze Age palace. In the same year, he excavated on the western slope of the citadel, in the area of a Hellenistic tower, and uncovered a building complex later identified as part of the site's "Cult Centre".

In 1887, Tsountas commenced his excavations of the cemeteries outside the citadel of Mycenae, considering the graves excavated in Circle A to be "royal" and consequently seeking to find what he considered the burials of the rest of the site's population. Between 1887 and 1898, Tsountas excavated 103 chamber tombs and three previously unknown tholos tombs (known as the Tomb of Aegisthus, the Panagia Tholos and the Tomb of the Genii), while he also cleared four tholoi that had already been discovered. In 2006, Tsountas's excavations represented just under half of the total number of chamber tombs excavated at Mycenae, though the sparse documentation made by Tsountas has limited their use for archaeological study.

In 1888, Tsountas made further excavations of the palace, as well as in the eastern part of the citadel, particularly the North East Extension and Mycenae's subterranean cistern, which he discovered. Excavations here continued in 1889, during which time Tsountas made further explorations of the south-western part of the citadel, uncovering a series of buildings over several seasons of work but making little record of them. In 1890, he cleared the northern and north-western slopes of the city; by 1893, he had progressed to the North Gate. In 1895 and 1896, he cleared the eastern and western slopes of the acropolis, and returned in 1896 to the south-western slope. This left unexcavated only a small area on the western slope of the citadel, now known as the "Citadel House" area.

Tsountas's notes on the excavations of the site's chamber tombs were inconsistent, and often left little evidence as to which tomb was being referred to; in the 1990s, the archaeologist Kim Shelton established the correspondence between many of the tombs excavated and numbered by Tsountas and the archaeological remains still visible at the site. His discovery of Egyptian material within the citadel established its date as belonging to the Late Bronze Age. In the late 1880s, he excavated the two tholos tombs known as Kato Phournos and Epano Phournos, which had previously been believed to be gates. In 1891, he excavated the Tomb of Clytemnestra. In contrast to the orthodoxy then prevalent, Tsountas considered the chamber tombs and tholoi at the site to postdate the shaft graves of Circle A. He also disavowed the association, claimed by Schliemann, between the burials at Mycenae and the characters of the Homeric epics. From 1899 to 1903, he was responsible for the consolidation and restoration of the monuments at Mycenae.

Thessaly

The region of Thessaly, in northern Greece, had been the subject of brief and informal antiquarian investigations in the final decades of Ottoman rule prior to 1881. This included visits from foreign antiquarians as well as a study by the medical doctor Nikolaos Georgiades, who published a historical, geographical and topographical study of the region in 1880. The region was incorporated into the Greek state in 1881, and therefore came under the jurisdiction of the Greek Archaeological Service; this development intensified efforts to collect and conserve known antiquities, still largely on an informal basis – the headteachers of local gymnasia would often be designated by the Archaeological Service as "Occasional Collectors of Antiquities" and organise small collections of portable finds, sometimes working alongside foreign scholars such as the German archaeologist Habbo Gerhard Lolling. The Archaeological Service occasionally sent representatives to conduct rescue excavations, as did the Archaeological Society of Athens, which established several local collections of artefacts, including one in a primary school at Larissa which included 166 objects.

In 1889, Tsountas, who was by then the Head of Antiquities for the Archaeological Society, made the first systematic archaeological investigation of the area. His first excavation was that of a Mycenaean burial tumulus at Marmariani. In the course of excavating five Mycenaean tombs at the site, he uncovered levels of settlement deposits dating to the Neolithic period, providing the first evidence of Neolithic material in Greece and demonstrating that mounds of this kinds, known as magoules, could be tells formed from the deposited layers of settlements of successive periods. Tsountas subsequently excavated Mycenaean tombs at the mound known as Kastron (ancient Iolkos) near Volos in 1900, at Volos itself in 1901–1903, and at Sesklo from 1901 to 1902. His colleague Stais had conducted excacations at Dimini in 1901–1902; Stais subsequently withdrew from Thessaly to focus on his work in Attica, and Tsountas received permission from him and the Archaeological Society to carry on the excavation of Dimini. In 1903, he uncovered three defensive walls at the site. Volos, Sesklo and Dimini subsequently became considered type sites for the Neolithic period in Greece. Tsountas continued to visit and conduct field survey in Thessaly each summer until 1906.

Cyclades and other islands

Tsountas was one of the first archaeologists to excavate in the Cycladic Islands. In September 1894, he excavated the cemetery of Amorgos, an island already known for its quantity of prehistoric remains, including graves dating to the Early and Middle Bronze Age. He was guided by a local priest, Dimitrios Prasinos, who had previously directed other archaeological visitors to the island and sold low-value antiquities to foreign archaeologists, including Duncan Mackenzie. During a short visit to the island, Tsountas discovered that the island's two largest cemeteries, at Kapros and Dokathismata, had been extensively looted by illegal excavators, among whom he named Prasinos and Ioannis Palailogos. Palailogos was arrested in September 1894 for smuggling looted antiquities from Amorgos to Athens, and Tsountas was called to make a report on the smuggled goods. In 1897, Tsountas excavated the cemetery of Krasades on Antiparos.

Tsountas coined the term Cycladic culture after his research of 1898–1899. In those two years, he excavated the cemetery of Chalandriani and the associated fortified settlement of Kastri on the island of Syros. He also excavated several hundred other Cycladic graves in cemeteries on the islands of Siphnos, Paros and Despotiko. On Siphnos, he excavated the site of Agios Andreas, uncovering the site's double circuit walls with its towers. Tsountas published his findings from the Cyclades in the Archaeological Journal, a scholarly publication of the Archaeological Society of Athens: his 1898 article may have been the first systematic study of the economic life of an archaeological site, though his conclusion that fish played only a small role in the Cycladic diet has since been overturned.

Tsountas excavated frequently on the island of Euboea, which he considered an important influence on the Cycladic Syros culture. In 1885, he excavated the necropolis to the west of the ancient city of Eretria. In 1886, 1891 and 1892, Tsountas made further excavations of the cemeteries around the city, which had been looted by antiquities traders; from 1886 onwards, he also supervised excavations undertaken by private landowners on their own land near Eretria. He worked on Euboea again in 1903, excavating six tombs at the cemetery of Manika near Chalkis. In March–May 1905, Tsountas made a 46-day visit to Crete, then an autonomous province of the Ottoman Empire, at the request of the board of the Archaeological Society, surveying its archaeological remains. He was assisted by Stefanos Xanthoudidis, the Ephor of Antiquities for Crete; Iosif Chatzidakis, the founder of the Heraklion Archaeological Museum; Arthur Evans, the archaeologist of the Minoan palace of Knossos; and Harriet Boyd, who had discovered and excavated the site of Gournia. The following year, the Cretan government accepted a request from the Archaeological Society for an excavation at the site of Malia: the project was due to begin in the same year under Tsountas.

Later career

On 24 February [O.S. 11 February] 1904, Tsountas was elected as Professor of the History of Ancient Art of the University of Athens; Kavvadias was also elected to a professorship on the same occasion. According to the archaeologist Christos Karouzos, who studied under Tsountas, he was reluctant to accept the post, but was persuaded to do so by the university. His appointment largely marked the end of his career as an excavator: from 1904, he focused his academic work on teaching and writing. Between 1909 and 1911, he served as general secretary of the Archaeological Society of Athens.

In February 1919, Tsountas was appointed as a founding professor of the "Practical School of Art History", an archaeological training centre administered by the Archaeological Society on behalf of the Greek government. The school's thirty-six students in its first year included Karouzos, Semni Papaspyridi and Spyridon Marinatos, all of whom went on to become leading figures in twentieth-century Greek archaeology. Tsountas has been credited as a particular influence on Papaspyridi, and marked one of the examination papers necessary for her to join the Archaeological Service in 1921. Encouraged by Arthur Evans, Tsountas granted permission for the British archaeologist Alan Wace to excavate at Mycenae in the early 1920s. Wace subsequently excavated in the Tomb of Aegisthus, which Tsountas had discovered in 1892, and throughout the site of Mycenae: his investigations confirmed several of Tsountas's theories as to the chronology of the site and the nature of Mycenaean civilisation. Another of Tsountas's students was George E. Mylonas, who would later direct the excavation of Mycenae between 1957 and 1985.

Tsountas retired from the University of Athens in 1925, though taught for the 1925–1926 academic year at the University of Thessaloniki. In 1926, he was made a member of the Academy of Athens, Greece's national academy. He died in 1934. The place of his burial is unknown: the historian Eleni Manteli has suggested that the Greek state likely neglected to organise a funeral or memorial for him.

Beliefs about Greek culture

Tsountas believed that Greek culture had existed in a continuous form since the prehistoric period, developing the ideas of historians such as Constantine Paparrigopoulos, who had sought in the mid-nineteenth century to challenge the then-popular view that the population of modern Greece had no biological or cultural descent from that of the classical period. Though he did not engage in the contemporary debate as to the geographic origins of the Mycenaean population, he reconstructed a rivalry between Mycenae and Troy which he described as part of the "eternal Eastern Question", connecting the mythical Trojan War with the Greco-Persian Wars of the classical period and the Greek War of Independence.

Tsountas argued in particular that Mycenaean civilisation was fundamentally Greek, and directed his reconstruction of prehistory towards the construction of contemporary Greek national identity. Though such efforts were common among Greek archaeologists of the nineteenth century, by the end of the century, Tsountas was one of extremely few who continued to espouse Romantic nationalism and to view his archaeological work through its paradigm. Tsountas argued that the Mycenaeans had originally been immigrants from northern Europe, with genetic commonalities with the Germans, Celts and Italians. Like other archaeologists and folklorists of his day, such as the German Arthur Milchhöfer and the French Georges Perrot, Tsountas assessed the cultural continuity of Greece through perceived similarities in vernacular customs and architecture; he drew attention, for example, to the similar shape of hearths found in Mycenaean dwellings and modern Greek peasant homes.

Tsountas was relatively unusual among Greek intellectuals of his time in considering the Byzantine period – then generally viewed as a period of foreign domination – a vital part of the Greek national narrative. The historiographical debate over the role of Byzantium in Greek history was partly played out through the Greek language question: the national debate as to whether Greek should be spoken in the prestige katharevousa dialect, which attempted to minimise post-classical features in favour of those found in Ancient Greek, or in the demotic dialect, which represented the natural language of most Greeks and implied an acceptance of the changes in the language that took place, inter alia, during the Byzantine period. In 1914, Tsountas appeared as a witness in the Nafplio Trial, a court case over the closure of a girls' school which had broken educational norms by teaching in demotic instead katharevousa; Tsountas testified in favour of the use of demotic. His positive views of the Byzantine period were unpopular within the Archaeological Society of Athens, described by the historian Fani Mallouchou-Tufano as "an intransigent ideological exponent of pure Classicism", which generally neglected the study of Byzantine archaeology in favour of that of the classical period.

Assessment and legacy

In an obituary of Tsountas published in the newspaper Nea Estia, his former student Karouzos described him as an "excellent teacher ... [and] modest man" with a "Socratic" appearance. The French archaeologist Charles Picard, a former director of the French School at Athens, similarly described him as "an enthusiastic savant, modest and courteous ... [who] always showed a most generous attitude towards the foreign schools of archaeology".

Recognition and honours

On 24 November [O.S. 12 November] 1892, Tsountas was awarded the Silver Cross of the Order of the Redeemer, Greece's national order of merit, for services to archaeology. He was awarded the Prussian Order of the Red Eagle (fourth class) on 20 February [O.S. 8 February] 1900, and the Gold Cross of the Order of the Redeemer on 3 September [O.S. 21 August] 1914. He was made an honorary member of the British Society for the Promotion of Hellenic Studies. The part of the Cult Centre which he excavated in 1886 is known as "Tsountas's House" after him.

Reception of Tsountas's archaeological work

Tsountas has been considered an underappreciated figure in Aegean archaeology, particularly by comparison to non-Greek archaeologists such as Schliemann, Wace and Evans. The archaeologist Sofia Voutsaki has named Tsountas as a pioneer of Greek archaeology and called him "the first and most eminent Greek prehistorian". The archaeologist Jack Davis has judged that Tsountas had greater influence on the field of Greek prehistory than any other archaeologist. According to the historian Cathy Gere, Tsountas is "the individual who properly deserves the title of Father of the Greek Bronze Age". Shelton has particularly credited Tsountas with taking the site of Mycenae and Mycenaean civilisation "out of Schliemann's spotlight". His excavations in Thessaly have been credited by the archaeologist Curtis Runnels as the beginning of the systematic investigation of the Greek Stone Age.

Tsountas popularised the term Mycenaean to refer to the civilisation of the Greek mainland in the Late Bronze Age. His book Mycenae and the Mycenaean Age, first published in 1893, became a standard textbook on Greek prehistory. He is credited with establishing Thessaly as the primary locus of research into Neolithic Greece, while his work in the Cyclades has been recognised with beginning the study of the prehistoric period in those islands. He also played a large role in the formation of the National Archaeological Museum's collection of prehistoric artefacts.

Tsountas's views of Mycenaean civilisation as fundamentally Greek were initially at odds with the prevailing opinion in scholarship outside Greece, which variously saw the burials in Grave Circle A – before Tsountas's work, considered the totality of evidence for Mycenaean civilisation – as belonging to Near Eastern, Egyptian, Slavic or northern-European cultures. The German philologist Ulrich Köhler, who directed the German Archaeological Institute at Athens, described them as having "nowhere a trace of the Greek spirit, nor of any Greek customs and beliefs", and as of "an exclusively oriental character".

Tsountas has been criticised for underestimating the value of pottery as archaeological evidence, and for throwing away ceramic material during his excavations. In most cases, he retained only finds of metal and of stone, as well as intact vases – which were extremely rare – and discarded the remainder. Though he kept notebooks during his excavations of Mycenae, averaging approximately ten pages of notes for every month of his work, he often excavated without keeping a journal and without the use of photography. The archaeological historian Vassiliki Pliatsika has written that modern archaeological standards, such as the systematic recording of finds and their contexts, are "deafeningly absent" from Tsountas's reports. Since Tsountas's excavations, studies of the spoil created by them has revealed important potsherds, representing substantial fragments of vessels as well as evidence for the later occupation of Mycenae after the end of the Bronze Age.

Tsountas's hypothesis that Mycenae's multiple cemeteries reflected an original pattern of settlement in disparate villages, first advanced in his 1888 article on the excavation of Mycenae's tombs, became the accepted model for Mycenae and for Mycenaean civilisation in general, but was disproved by further study in the early 1990s. His assertion that Mycenaean society was illiterate was overturned by the discovery of Linear B tablets at Pylos in 1939, and subsequently, under Alan Wace, at Mycenae in 1952. Tsountas also argued that Mycenaean society had been matriarchal and that Mycenaean religion had been based around a "goddess of generation". By the late nineteenth century, this view was widely accepted, though it has since been overturned.