Lably
Skip to content

Force field (chemistry)

Concept on molecular modeling

  • 22 min read
  • 7 chapters

Related on Lably

Through Chemistry, Function (mathematics) and Parameter

A large number of different force field types exist today (e.g. for organic molecules, ions, polymers, minerals, and metals). Depending on the material, different functional forms are usually chosen for the force fields since different types of atomistic interactions dominate the material behavior.

There are various criteria that can be used for categorizing force field parametrization strategies. An important differentiation is 'component-specific' and 'transferable'. For a component-specific parametrization, the considered force field is developed solely for describing a single given substance (e.g. water). For a transferable force field, all or some parameters are designed as building blocks and become transferable/ applicable for different substances (e.g. methyl groups in alkane transferable force fields). A different important differentiation addresses the physical structure of the models: All-atom force fields provide parameters for every type of atom in a system, including hydrogen, while united-atom interatomic potentials treat the hydrogen and carbon atoms in methyl groups and methylene bridges as one interaction center. Coarse-grained potentials, which are often used in long-time simulations of macromolecules such as proteins, nucleic acids, and multi-component complexes, sacrifice chemical details for higher computing efficiency.

Force fields for molecular systems

The basic functional form of potential energy for modeling molecular systems includes intramolecular interaction terms for interactions of atoms that are linked by covalent bonds, and intermolecular (i.e. nonbonded also termed noncovalent) terms that describe the long-range electrostatic and van der Waals forces. The specific decomposition of the terms depends on the force field, but a general form for the total energy in an additive force field can be written as Etotal=Ebonded+Enonbonded where the components of the covalent and noncovalent contributions are given by the following summations: Ebonded=Ebond+Eangle+Edihedral Enonbonded=Eelectrostatic+Evan der Waals

The bond and angle terms are usually modeled by quadratic energy functions that do not allow bond breaking. A more realistic description of a covalent bond at higher stretching is provided by the more expensive Morse potential. The functional form for dihedral energy is variable from one force field to another. Additionally, "improper torsional" terms may be added to enforce the planarity of aromatic rings and other conjugated systems, and "cross-terms" that describe the coupling of different internal variables, such as angles and bond lengths. Some force fields also include explicit terms for hydrogen bonds.

The nonbonded terms are computationally most intensive. A popular choice is to limit interactions to pairwise energies. The van der Waals term is usually computed with a Lennard-Jones potential or the Mie potential and the electrostatic term with Coulomb's law. However, both can be buffered or scaled by a constant factor to account for electronic polarizability. A large number of force fields based on this or similar energy expressions have been proposed in the past decades for modeling different types of materials such as molecular substances, metals, glasses etc. - see below for a comprehensive list of force fields.

Bonded terms

Bond potential

As it is rare for bonds to deviate significantly from their equilibrium values, the most simplistic approaches utilize a Hooke's law formula: Ebond=kij2(lij−l0,ij)2, where kij is the force constant, lij is the bond length, and l0,ij is the value for the bond length between atoms i and j when all other terms in the force field are set to 0. The term l0,ij is at times differently defined or taken at different thermodynamic conditions.

The bond stretching constant kij can be determined from the experimental infrared spectrum, Raman spectrum, or high-level quantum-mechanical calculations. The constant kij determines vibrational frequencies in molecular dynamics simulations. The stronger the bond is between atoms, the higher is the value of the force constant, and the higher the wavenumber (energy) in the IR/Raman spectrum.

Though the formula of Hooke's law provides a reasonable level of accuracy at bond lengths near the equilibrium distance, it is less accurate as one moves away. In order to model the Morse curve better, one could employ cubic and higher powers. However, for most practical applications these differences are negligible, and inaccuracies in predictions of bond lengths are on the order of the thousandth of an angstrom, which is also the limit of reliability for common force fields. A Morse potential can be employed instead to enable bond breaking and higher accuracy, even though it is less efficient to compute. For reactive force fields, bond breaking and bond orders are additionally considered.

Angle potential

Angular vibrations are usually described through a spring equation as well:

Eangles=kiangle(θi−θ0)2

where kiangle is the force constant, θi the angle between three atoms and θ0 the equilibrium angle.

Dihedral potential

A dihedral potential, also called a torsion potential, is often described by the following function:

Edihedral=kidihedral[1+cos⁡(niϕi+δi)]

where kidihedral is the force constant, ϕi the dihedral angle, δi the phase and n defines the number of minima or maxima between 0 and 2π.

Dihedral terms admit a range of mathematical representations, as illustrated by the multiple dihedral functional forms provided in OpenMM's standard forces.

Non-bonded terms

Electrostatic interactions

Electrostatic interactions are represented by a Coulomb energy, which utilizes atomic charges qi to represent chemical bonding ranging from covalent to polar covalent and ionic bonding. The typical formula is the Coulomb law: ECoulomb=14πε0qiqjrij, where rij is the distance between two atoms i and j. The total Coulomb energy is a sum over all pairwise combinations of atoms and usually excludes 1, 2 bonded atoms, 1, 3 bonded atoms, as well as 1, 4 bonded atoms.

Atomic charges can make dominant contributions to the potential energy, especially for polar molecules and ionic compounds, and are critical to simulate the geometry, interaction energy, and the reactivity. The assignment of charges usually uses some heuristic approach, with different possible solutions.

Historically the electrostatic potential (ESP) has been used to determine partial charges with the Merz-Kollman method being one of the first. Other methods uses population based analysis schemes of wavefunctions like the Mulliken or Löwdin population analysis.

Another method to derive partial charges are charge equilibration methods like EEM, SQE or ACKS2. The idea is to assign geometry-dependent charges by letting electronegativity differences drive charge flow between atoms until a self-consistent minimum of the electrostatic energy is reached.

Sign in to keep reading

6 more chapters are free with a Lably account.

More in Chemistry