Lably
Skip to content

Folk Orthodoxy

Variety of regional or ethnic syncretic expressions of Eastern Orthodoxy

  • 32 min read
  • 5 chapters

Related on Lably

Through Agriculture and Middle Ages

Folk orthodoxy has developed from an interpretation of rituals, sacred texts, and characters from the Bible. In folk orthodoxy, religious syncretism coexists with Christian doctrine and elements of pre-Christian pagan beliefs. According to historian and ethnologist Sergei Anatolievich Shtyrkov, the boundary between canonical and folk orthodoxy is not clear or constant; it is drawn by religious institutions such as the Russian Orthodox Church (which often consider folk orthodoxy superstition or paganism).

Dual faith

The Russian-language term dvoeverie ("dual faith", двоеверие) appeared during the Middle Ages, used in sermons directed against Christians who continued to worship pagan deities. Dvoeverie refers to the conflict between two religious systems: paganism and Christianity. The term religious syncretism, on the other hand, implies a set of blended beliefs.

The phenomenon of "dual faith" originated in the Christian Church. In early Christianity, the church denounced non-canonical religious practices. In the fourth-century Eastern Roman Empire, Asterius of Amasia (c. 350 – c. 410) opposed the celebration of calends in his sermons. Basil the Great (c. 350 – c. 410) denounced his Christian contemporaries for practicing grave-site commemoration, which took on characteristics often seen during the pagan festival Lupercalia. In the Western Roman Empire, Church Fathers also denounced some Christians for practicing the remnants of pagan customs.

Elements of dual faith inhere in several Christian cultures. One example is All Souls' Day and All Hallow's Eve (better known as Halloween). Halloween is an ancient Celtic pagan holiday commemorating ancestors, similar to the Christian feast-day All Saints' Day. A number of Christian cultures celebrate Carnival before Great Lent, which preserves pre-Christian customs, thus combining pagan and Christian customs.

In Russia, this concept appears with the church's opposition to paganism. According to The word of a certain Christ-lover and zealot for the right faith:

... So also this so-called "Christian" could not tolerate Christians who double-mindedly live, who believe in Peruna, Khorsa, Mokosh and Simargl, and in fairies, whom the ignorant say, the triune sisters consider them goddesses and offer sacrifices to them and cut chickens, they pray to fire, calling it Svarozhich, they deify garlic, and when one has a feast, then they put it in buckets and bowls, and so they drink, rejoicing in their idols".

Criticism

According to philologist Viktor Zhivov, the synthesis of pagan and Christian cultural elements is typical of all European cultures; dual faith is not unique to Russian spirituality.

American researcher Eve Levin believes that a significant part of medieval Russian folk orthodoxy has Christian origins. Levin cites Paraskevi of Iconium, who was considered a Christian replacement for the goddess Mokosh in folk religion.

Ethnographer Alexander Strakhov (1948–2021) writes, "Since the nineteenth century, we have been quite convinced that it is worth stripping off the pagan rites superimposed, in a thin layer, [over] the Christian colors, so that the features of ancient pagan beliefs are revealed."

Strakhov disagrees; according to his monograph, The Night Before Christmas: "Under the 'pagan' appearance of a rite or belief, there is often a quite Christian basis."

Folklorist Alexander Panchenko (b. 1971) writes:

We do not have many methods for determining the antiquity of certain phenomena of mass (especially oral) culture. 'Archaism' of many cultural forms investigated by domestic ethnologists and folklorists is a scientific illusion. What was considered a 'legacy of paganism' is often a comparatively late phenomenon that emerged in the context of Christian culture ... I think the pursuit of the archaic is another way of constructing the 'alien' – that 'obscure object of desire' of colonial anthropology.

According to historian Vladimir Petrukhin (b. 1950), there was no pagan worldview separate from the Christian one in medieval Russia; the people perceived themselves as Christians. Customs considered relics of paganism had a literary origin or belonged to the secular culture of the time.

Folklorist Nikita Tolstoy (1923–1996), noting the primitive nature of dual faith, proposed the term troeverie ("triple faith"). The third component of the worldview of the Russian middle ages was the folk, "non-canonical" culture of Byzantium, the Balkans, and Europe, which arrived in Russia with Christianity in the form of skomorokhs, Foolishness for Christ, and koliada. The concept of "triple faith" has also been applied by Andrey P. Zabiyako (1961- ) and Anna A. Zabiyako to the mixture of Russian folk-beliefs with those of other cultures such as Chinese folk religion.

Sign in to keep reading

4 more chapters are free with a Lably account.

More in Religious figures