Starfish

Life cycle

Sexual reproduction

Most species of starfish are gonochorous, with there being separate male and female individuals. Some species are simultaneous hermaphrodites, producing eggs and sperm at the same time, and in a few of these the same gonad, called an ovotestis, produces both eggs and sperm. Other starfish are sequential hermaphrodites. Protandrous individuals of species like Asterina gibbosa start life as males before changing sex into females as they grow older. In some species such as Nepanthia belcheri, a large female can split in half and the resulting offspring are males. When these grow large enough they change back into females.

Each starfish arm contains two gonads that release gametes through openings called gonoducts, located on the central disc between the arms. Fertilization is generally external but in a few species, internal fertilization takes place. In most species, the buoyant eggs and sperm are simply released into the water (free spawning) and the resulting embryos and larvae live as part of the plankton. In others, the eggs may be stuck to the undersides of rocks. In certain species of starfish, the females brood their eggs – either by simply enveloping them or by holding them in specialised structures in different parts of the body, externally or internally. Those starfish that brood their eggs by "sitting" on them usually assume a humped posture with their discs raised off the substrate. Pteraster militaris broods a few of its young and disperses the remaining eggs, which are too numerous to fit into its pouch. In these brooding species, the eggs are relatively large, supplied with yolk, and generally develop directly into miniature starfish without an intervening larval stage, called "lecithotrophic". In Parvulastra parvivipara, an intragonadal brooder, the young starfish obtain nutrients by eating other eggs and embryos in the brood pouch. Brooding occurs in species that live in colder waters, as well as in smaller species that produce just a few eggs.

The timing of spawning may be influenced by lighting conditions, water temperature, food availability, and other factors. Individuals may gather together to release their gametes at once, using pheromones to attract each other. In some species, a male and female may come together and form a pair. They engage in pseudocopulation which involves the male crawling on the female; the male fertilises the gametes while the female releases them.

Larval development

Starfish embryos typically hatch as blastulas. Invaginations take place; the first, forming the anus, is created from the blastopore, while a second, taking place in the ectodermic layer, creates the mouth. The archenteron stretches towards the mouth and connects with it, forming the gut. A band of cilia develops on the exterior. This enlarges and extends around the surface and eventually onto two developing arm-like outgrowths. At this stage the larva is known as a bipinnaria. The cilia are used for locomotion and feeding, their rhythmic beat wafting phytoplankton towards the mouth.

The next stage in development is a brachiolaria larva, and involves the growth of three short ventral-anterior arms with adhesive tips surrounding a sucker. Both bipinnaria and brachiolaria larvae are bilaterally symmetrical. When fully developed, the brachiolaria settles on the seabed and attaches itself with a short stalk made from its ventral arms and sucker. Metamorphosis now takes place with a radical rearrangement of tissues. The larvae develops an oral surface on the left and an aboral surface on the right. While the gut remains, the mouth and anus move to new positions. Some of the body cavities disappear while others become the water vascular system and the visceral coelom. The starfish is now pentaradially symmetrical. It casts off its stalk and becomes a free-living juvenile starfish up to 1 mm (0.04 in) in diameter.

Asexual reproduction

Some species of starfish can reproduce asexually as adults either by fission of their central discs or by autotomy (self-amputation) of one or more of their arms. Single arms that regenerate a whole individual are called comet forms. The larvae of several species of starfish can reproduce asexually before they reach maturity. They do this by autotomising some parts of their bodies or by budding. Larvae increase asexual reproduction when they sense that food is plentiful. Though this costs time and energy and delays maturity, it allows a single larva to give rise to multiple adults when the conditions are appropriate.

Regeneration

Some species of starfish have the ability to regenerate lost arms and can regrow an entire new limb given time. A few can regrow a complete new disc from a single arm, while others need at least part of the central disc to be attached to the detached part. Regrowth can take several months, and starfish are vulnerable to infections during the early stages after the loss of an arm. Other than fragmentation carried out for the purpose of reproduction, the division of the body may happen as a defense mechanism. The loss of body parts is achieved by the rapid softening of a special type of connective tissue in response to nervous signals. This type of tissue is called catch connective tissue and is found in most echinoderms. An autotomy-promoting factor has been identified which, when injected into another starfish, causes rapid shedding of arms.

Lifespan

The lifespan of a starfish varies considerably among species. For example, Leptasterias hexactis reaches sexual maturity at 20 g (0.7 oz) in two years and lives for about ten years. Pisaster ochraceus matures at 70–90 g (2.5–3.2 oz) in five years and has a maximum recorded lifespan of 34 years.

Ecology

Distribution and habitat

Starfish live in marine waters around the world including both tropical and polar waters. They are mainly benthic animals, living in sandy, muddy and rocky substrates. They range from shallow, intertidal waters to the deep-sea floor down to at least 6,000 m (20,000 ft). Starfish are most common along the coast.

Diet

Most species are generalist predators, eating microalgae, sponges, bivalves, snails and other small animals. The crown-of-thorns starfish consumes coral polyps, while other species are detritivores, feeding on decomposing organic material and faecal matter. A few are suspension feeders, gathering in phytoplankton; Henricia and Echinaster often feed with sponges, taking advantage of the water current they produce. Various species can absorb organic nutrients from the surrounding water, and this may form a significant portion of their diet.

The processes of feeding and capture may be aided by special parts; Pisaster brevispinus, the short-spined pisaster from the West Coast of America, can use a set of specialized tube feet to dig itself deep into the soft substrate to extract prey (usually clams). Grasping the shellfish, the starfish slowly pries open the prey's shell, overcoming the clam's adductor muscle, and inserts its everted stomach into the crack to digest the soft tissues. The gap between the clam's valves need only be a fraction of a millimetre wide for the stomach to gain entry.

Ecological impact

Starfish are keystone species in their respective marine communities. Their relatively large sizes, diverse diets, and ability to adapt to different environments makes them ecologically important. The term "keystone species" was in fact first used by Robert Paine in 1966 to describe a starfish, Pisaster ochraceus. When studying the low intertidal coasts of Washington state, Paine found that predation by P. ochraceus was a major factor in the diversity of species. Experimental removals of this top predator from a stretch of shoreline resulted in lower species diversity and the eventual domination of Mytilus mussels, which were able to outcompete other organisms for space and resources. Similar results were found in a 1971 study of Stichaster australis on the intertidal coast of the South Island of New Zealand. S. australis was found to have removed most of a batch of transplanted mussels within two or three months of their placement, while in an area from which S. australis had been removed, the mussels increased in number dramatically, overwhelming the area and threatening biodiversity.

The feeding activity of the omnivorous starfish Oreaster reticulatus on sandy and seagrass bottoms near the Virgin Islands effects the composition of communities of microorganisms. These starfish engulf piles of sediment removing the surface films and algae adhering to the particles. Organisms that dislike this disturbance are replaced by others better able to rapidly recolonise "clean" sediment. In addition, foraging by these starfish creates diverse patches of organic matter, which may attract larger organisms such as fish, crabs and sea urchins that feed on the sediment.

Starfish sometimes have negative effects on ecosystems. Outbreaks of crown-of-thorns starfish have caused damage to coral reefs in Northeast Australia and French Polynesia. A study in Polynesia found that coral cover declined drastically with the arrival of migratory starfish in 2006, dropping over 40% to under 5% in four years. This in turn had a cascade effect on both sessile bottom-dwelling animals and reef fish. Asterias amurensis is a rare example of an invasive echinoderm. Its larvae likely arrived in Tasmania from central Japan via water discharged from ships in the 1980s. The species has since grown in numbers to the point where they threaten important bivalve fisheries in Australia. As such, they are considered pests, and are on the Invasive Species Specialist Group's list of the world's 100 worst invasive species. Some species that prey on bivalve molluscs can transmit paralytic shellfish poisoning.

Threats

Starfish may be preyed on by conspecifics, sea anemones, other starfish species, tritons, crabs, fish, gulls, and sea otters. Their first lines of defence are the saponins present in their body walls, which have unpleasant flavours. Some starfish such as Astropecten polyacanthus also include powerful toxins such as tetrodotoxin, while the slime star can ooze out large quantities of repellent mucus. The crown-of-thorns starfish possesses sharp spines, toxins and bright warning colours.

Several species sometimes suffer from a wasting condition caused by Vibrio bacteria. A more widespread sea star wasting disease sporadically causes mass mortalities. The results of a 2025 study of starfish off the coast of central British Columbia suggest that those living in the fjords can better survive outbreaks of the disease due to the lower temperatures and higher salinity of their environment.

The protozoan Orchitophrya stellarum is known to infect and damage the gonads of starfish. Starfish are vulnerable to high temperatures. Experiments have shown that the feeding and growth rates of Pisaster ochraceus reduce greatly when their body temperatures rise above 23 °C (73 °F) and that they die when their temperature rises to 30 °C (86 °F). This species has a unique ability to absorb seawater to keep itself cool when it is exposed to sunlight by a receding tide. It also appears to rely on its arms to absorb heat, so as to protect the central disc and vital organs.

Starfish and other echinoderms can be vulnerable to marine pollution. The common starfish is considered to be a bioindicator species for marine ecosystems. A 2009 study found that P. ochraceus is unlikely to be affected by ocean acidification as severely as other marine animals with calcareous skeletons. In other groups, structures made of calcium carbonate are vulnerable to dissolution when the pH is lowered. Researchers found that when P. ochraceus were exposed to 21 °C (70 °F) and 770 parts per million of carbon dioxide (beyond rises expected in the next century), they were relatively unaffected. Their survival is likely due to the nodular nature of their skeletons, which are able to compensate for a shortage of carbonate by growing more fleshy tissue.

Evolution

Fossil record

The earliest fossil echinoderms date to the Cambrian, with the first asterozoans (a group that includes starfish and brittle stars) being the Somasteroidea, which exhibit traits of both groups. Starfish are infrequently found as fossils, possibly because their hard skeletal components separate as the animal decays. Despite this, there are a few places where accumulations of complete skeletal structures occur, fossilized in place in Lagerstätten – so-called "starfish beds".

By the late Paleozoic, the crinoids and blastoids were the predominant echinoderms, fragments of which are almost the only fossil found in some limestones. In the two major extinction events that occurred during the late Devonian and late Permian, the blastoids were wiped out and only a few species of crinoids survived. Many starfish species also became extinct in these events, but afterwards the surviving few species quickly diversified rapidly over sixty million years between the beginning and middle of the Middle Jurassic. A 2012 study found that speciation in starfish can occur rapidly. During the last 6,000 years, divergence in the larval development of Cryptasterina hystera and Cryptasterina pentagona has taken place, the former adopting internal fertilization and brooding and the latter remaining a broadcast spawner.

Diversity

The scientific name Asteroidea was given to starfish by the French zoologist de Blainville in 1830. It is derived from the Greek aster, ἀστήρ (a star) and the Greek eidos, εἶδος (form, likeness, appearance). Starfish are included in the subphylum Asterozoa along with brittle and basket stars (order Ophiuroidea), the characteristics of which include a star-shaped body as adults, with multiple arms surrounding central disc. The arms of asteroids are skeletally connected to the disc by ossicles in the body wall while ophiuroids have clearly demarcated arms.

The starfish are a large and diverse class with over 1,900 living species. There are seven extant orders: Brisingida, Forcipulatida, Notomyotida, Paxillosida, Spinulosida, Valvatida and Velatida. Living asteroids, the Neoasteroidea, are distinct from their forerunners in the Paleozoic. Their classification has changed little but there is debate in regards to Paxillosida. The deep-water sea daisies, though clearly Asteroidea and currently included in Velatida, do not fit easily in any accepted lineage. Phylogenetic data suggests that they may be a sister group, the Concentricycloidea, to the Neoasteroidea, or that the Velatida themselves may be a sister group.

Living groups

Brisingida (2 families, 17 genera, 111 species)

Species in this order have a small, rigid disc and 6–20 long, thin arms, which they use for suspension feeding. They have one series of marginal plates, disc plates merged in a ring, fewer numbers of aboral plates, crossed pedicellariae, and several series of long spines on the arms. They mostly live in deep-sea habitats, although a few live in shallow waters in the Antarctic. In some species, the tube feet have rounded tips and lack suckers.

Forcipulatida (6 families, 63 genera, 269 species)

Species in this order have distinctive pedicellariae, consisting of a short stalk with forceps-like tips. and tube feet with flat-tipped suckers usually arranged in four rows. The order includes well-known species from temperate and cold-water regions, ranging from intertidal to abyssal zones.

Notomyotida (1 family, 8 genera, 75 species)

These starfish are deep-sea dwelling and have particularly flexible arms with distinctive lines of musculature along the sides of the dorsal region. In some species, the tube feet lack suckers.

Paxillosida (7 families, 48 genera, 372 species)

This is a primitive order whose members do not extrude their stomach when feeding and both anus and tube feet suckers are absent. Papulae are present on their aboral surface, and they possess marginal plates and paxillae. They mostly inhabit soft substrates. There is no brachiolaria stage in their larval development. The comb starfish (Astropecten polyacanthus) is a member of this order.

Spinulosida (1 family, 8 genera, 121 species)

Most species in this order lack pedicellariae; all have a delicate skeletal arrangement with small or no marginal plates on the disc or arms. They have numerous groups of short spines on the aboral surface.

Valvatida (16 families, 172 genera, 695 species)

Most species in this order have five arms and two rows of tube feet with suckers. There are conspicuous marginal plates on the arms and disc. Some species have paxillae and in some, the main pedicellariae are clamp-like and recessed into the skeletal plates.

Velatida (4 families, 16 genera, 138 species)

This order of starfish consists mostly of deep-sea and other cold-water starfish often with a global distribution. The shape is pentagonal or star-shaped with five to fifteen arms. The skeleton is underdeveloped.

Extinct groups

Extinct groups within the Asteroidea include:

• † Calliasterellidae, with the type genus Calliasterella from the Devonian and Carboniferous
• † Palasteriscus, a Devonian genus
• † Trichasteropsida, with the Triassic genus Trichasteropsis (at least 2 species)

Phylogeny

External

Starfish are deuterostome animals, like the chordates. A 2014 analysis of 219 genes from all classes of echinoderms gives the following phylogenetic tree. The times at which the clades diverged are shown under the labels in millions of years ago (mya).

Internal

The phylogeny of the Asteroidea has been difficult to resolve, with visible (morphological) features proving inadequate, and the question of whether traditional taxa are clades apply. The phylogeny proposed by Gale in 1987 is:

The phylogeny proposed by Blake in 1987 is:

Later work making use of molecular evidence, with or without the use of morphological evidence, had by 2000 failed to resolve the argument. In 2011, on further molecular evidence, Janies and colleagues noted that the phylogeny of the echinoderms "has proven difficult", and that "the overall phylogeny of extant echinoderms remains sensitive to the choice of analytical methods". They presented a phylogenetic tree for the living Asteroidea only; using the traditional names of starfish orders where possible, and indicating "part of" otherwise, the phylogeny is shown below. The Solasteridae are split from the Velatida, and the old Spinulosida is broken up.

Human relations

In research

Starfish have been used in reproductive and developmental studies. Female starfish produce large numbers of oocytes that are easily isolated; these can be stored in a pre-meiosis phase and stimulated to complete division by the use of 1-methyladenine. Starfish oocytes are well suited for this research as they are easy to handle, can be maintained in sea water at room temperature, are transparent, and develop quickly. Asterina pectinifera, used as a model organism for this purpose, is resilient and easy to breed and maintain in the laboratory.

Another area of research is the ability of starfish to regenerate lost body parts. The stem cells of adult humans are incapable of much differentiation and understanding the regrowth, repair and cloning processes in starfish may have implications for human medicine.

Starfish have an unusual ability to displace foreign objects from their bodies, which makes them difficult to tag for research tracking purposes.

In legend and culture

An aboriginal Australian fable, retold by the Welsh school headmaster William Jenkyn Thomas (1870–1959), tells how some animals needed a canoe to cross the ocean. Whale had one but refused to lend it, so Starfish kept him busy, telling him stories and grooming him to remove parasites, while the others stole the canoe. When Whale realized the trick he beat Starfish ragged, which is how Starfish still is today.

In 1900, the scholar Edward Tregear documented The Creation Song, which he describes as "an ancient prayer for the dedication of a high chief" of Hawaii. Among the "uncreated gods" described early in the song is the starfish.

Georg Eberhard Rumpf's 1705 The Ambonese Curiosity Cabinet describes the tropical varieties of Stella Marina or Bintang Laut, "Sea Star" in Latin and Malay respectively, known in the waters around Ambon. He writes that the Histoire des Antilles reports that when the sea stars "see thunder storms approaching, [they] grab hold of many small stones with their little legs, looking to ... hold themselves down as if with anchors".

As food

Starfish are sometimes eaten in China, Japan, and Palau. Some species, such as the crown-of-thorns starfish, are toxic. Georg Eberhard Rumpf found few starfish being used for food in the Indonesian archipelago, other than as bait in fish traps, but on the island of "Huamobel" [sic], the people cut them up, squeeze out the "black blood" and cook them with sour tamarind leaves; after resting the pieces for a day or two, they remove the outer skin and cook them in coconut milk.

As collectables

Starfish are in some cases taken from their habitat and sold to tourists as souvenirs, ornaments, curios or for display in aquariums. In particular, Oreaster reticulatus, with its easily accessed habitat and bright coloration, is widely collected in the Caribbean. In the early to mid 20th century, this species was numerous along the West Indian coasts, but collection and trade have severely diminished its numbers. In the State of Florida, O. reticulatus is listed as endangered and its collection is illegal. Nevertheless, it is still sold both in and outside its range. A similar phenomenon exists in the Indo-Pacific for species such as Protoreaster nodosus.