Pure Land

Mahayana Pure Lands

Amitābha's Sukhāvatī

Sukhāvatī ("The Blissful") is by far the most popular pure land in East Asian Mahayana Buddhism. It is also the main goal of Pure Land Buddhism, which is centered around faith and devotion to Amitābha Buddha as the means of attaining rebirth in his pure land. It is also a popular pure land in Tibetan Buddhism as well. The key canonical teachings on Sukhāvatī are found in the "three pure land sutras", the main sources for East Asian Pure Land Buddhism: the Smaller Sukhāvatī-vyūha (T 366), the Longer Sukhāvatīvyūha Sūtra, and the Amitayus Contemplation Sutra (i.e. The Contemplation Sutra).

According to Mahayana scriptures, in his past life, Amitabha was a devoted king of a joyous kingdom in a distant eon who renounced his throne to become a monk and vowed to attain buddhahood. He made forty-eight vows which focus on the greatness of his future pure land, pledging that he would not accept buddhahood if any of these vows went unfulfilled. The vows are dedicated to establishing a pure realm accessible to all beings who aspired to be reborn there. This monk would ultimately become Buddha Amitabha. His vows were grounded in hearing his name ("Amitabha"), establishing virtue, and dedicating merit toward rebirth in this pure land.

Some Mahayana sutra teachings say that after Amitabha attains final nirvana, the successors of Amitabha in Sukhāvatī will be Avalokiteśvara, followed by Mahāsthāmaprāpta.

There are numerous East Asian texts discussing the various experiences of Pure Land Buddhists who have gone to the Pure land or had a vision of Sukhavati. Some Buddhists and followers of other religions claimed to have seen Sukhavati and numerous East Asian popular faiths and cults also discuss Sukhavati.

Śākyamuni's Pure Lands

The Mahāyāna Mahāparinirvāṇa Sūtra states that Śākyamuni Buddha has his own Pure Land which is far in the western direction. According to Charles Jones "this land is called “Unsurpassable” (Wúshèng 無勝) because it is the equal of both the western Land of Peace and Bliss (Ānlè shìjiè 安樂世界) and the eastern Land of the Full Moon (Mǎnyuè shìjiè 滿月世界). From his base in that pure land, Śākyamuni manifests in this world of Jambudvīpa in order to turn the wheel of dharma and save all its sentient beings (T.374.12:508c25–509a4)."

Śākyamuni Buddha is also associated with the assembly in open space over Vulture Peak, which is the site of the preaching of the Lotus Sutra and many other Mahayana sutras. This is considered to be a kind of Pure Land on earth. Tiantai tradition holds that while the founder Zhiyi was chanting the Lotus Sutra, he had a vision of this pure assembly. His teacher Nanyue Huisi is said to have told Zhiyi that they had met in a previous life at this assembly. The Japanese monk Nichiren taught his disciples that through faith in the Lotus Sutra, one could be reborn in the pure land of Vulture Peak after death, promoting it as an alternative postmortem destination to Sukhavati.

Japanese Buddhist schools like Tendai and Nichiren Buddhism see Śākyamuni's pure land as being continuous with this world. This becomes pronounced in Nichiren Buddhism, which affirms the non-duality of this world and the pure land of Vulture peak. Even when addressing one's postmortem destination, Nichiren insisted that the "pure land of Vulture Peak"—while including the deceased faithful—is also a sacred reality accessible in this world through faith in the Lotus Sutra. For Nichiren, the samsaric world itself, when properly understood and engaged through faith, is the eternally abiding pure land. This leads to the attainment of buddhahood in one's present body (sokushin jōbutsu), without rejecting samsara or aspiring to a realm beyond it. This pure land was also associated with the Land of Tranquil Light (jakkōdo 寂光土), the supreme pure land in the Tiantai system.

Pure Lands of Buddha Vairocana

According to the Buddhāvataṃsaka Sūtra, the whole universe is a vast pure buddha-field which has been purified by the cosmic Vairocana Buddha. This is the view of Pure Land which is found in the Chinese Huayan tradition and in Chinese Esoteric Buddhism. According to this view, our world is just one small part of this universal Pure Land which is named: "Ocean of worlds, whose surface and inside are decorated with an arrangement of flowers" (Sanskrit: Kusumatalagarbha-vyūhālamkāra-lokadhātusamudra). It is also called the "Lotus Treasury World" (Chinese: 華蔵世界, Skt. Padmagarbha-lokadhātu), since it is an array of billions of worlds in a lotus flower shape.

Furthermore, Ghanavyūha ("Dense Array" or "Secret Adornment") is considered to be the supreme pure buddhafield specific to Vairocana. It appears in Mahayana sutras like the Ghanavyūha Sutra. According to this sutra, by following virtuous teachers, hearing and contemplating Buddha Dharma, and letting go of all concepts and craving, one can be reborn there, achieve enlightenment, and manifest in countless ways to help all beings.

In East Asian Esoteric Buddhist traditions, like Shingon, the dual mandalas of the Vajradhatu and Garbhadhatu mandalas are considered to be the representation of the buddhafield of Mahāvairocana Buddha, the supreme cosmic Buddha.

Inner court of Tuṣita

The "Inner Court of Tushita" (兜率內院) is Maitreya's pure land, which is actually located in the deva realm of Tuṣita. Some Buddhist scriptures teach that Maitreya is currently teaching at the Inner Court of Tuṣita. Some Buddhist Masters, such as Xuanzang, expressed a wish to be reborn there.

Other Buddhist monks, such as Xuyun, also aspired to be reborn in the Inner Court of Tuṣita in order to meet Maitreya.

The Inner Court of Tuṣita was historically a popular place for Buddhists to wish to be reborn in; however, the vast majority of Pure Land Buddhists today hope to be reborn in Sukhavati.

Some followers of the Chinese Salvationist religion called Yiguandao have also claimed to have traveled there.

Pure Lands of the Five Tathāgatas

Later Indian Buddhism developed a schema of five main Buddhas (called the Five Tathāgatas). In this schema, which is popular in Esoteric Buddhism and is organized as a mandala, there the five Pure Lands of the five key Buddhas are:

• In the center, Akaniṣṭha-Ghanavyūha, hosted by Vairocana Buddha. In Tibetan Buddhism, Ghanavyūha Akaniṣṭha is the supreme Saṃbhogakāya buddhafield of Vajradhara, out of which emanate all Nirmāṇakāya Buddhas and Buddhafields such as Sukhāvati.
• In the East, Abhirati, hosted by Akṣobhya Buddha
• In the South, Śrīmat, hosted by Ratnasaṃbhava Buddha
• In the West, Sukhāvatī, hosted by Amitābha Buddha
• In the North, Karmaprasiddhi or Prakuṭā, hosted by Amoghasiddhi Buddha

Other identified Pure Lands

• Abhirati ("Joyous") is the buddhafield of Akshobhya Buddha, located in the eastern direction. This pure land is suggested by some scholars to be the earliest buddhafield mentioned in Mahayana sutras.
• Vaidūryanirbhāsa (“Pure Blue Beryl”, Ch: 東方淨琉璃世界) of Bhaiṣajyaguru in the east is compared by some Pure Land Buddhists to Amitabha's Pure Land in the west. Bhaiṣajyaguru is also said to have manifestations in six other Pure Lands.
• Vimala ("Spotless", "World Without Filth") is the pure land of bodhisattva Manjushri.
• The city Ketumati is also described as Maitreya's future Pure Land on earth.
• The female bodhisattva Tara was also held to have a pure land, either termed Khadiravaṇa (Acacia Forest) or "Turquoise Leaf Land" (Tibetan: Yulokod).
• Zangdok Palri (Glorious Copper Colored Mountain) the Pure Land of Padmasambhava described in Tibetan sources. Dudjom Rinpoche said it was prophesied that all who had taken refuge in Padmasambhava or anyone who had any sort of connection with him would be reborn in Zangdok Palri.
• Shambhala, a pure land in the Vajrayana Buddhist Kalachakra cycle of tantras and teachings.
• The pure land of Vajrayogini, called Khechara or Dhagpa Khadro.

In East Asian Buddhism

Transcendent land vs non-dual land

In Chinese Buddhism, the Pure Land was commonly seen as a transcendent realm beyond the three realms (the desire realm, form realm and formless realm) into which one can be reborn after death. This view is also called "other direction" or "western direction" pure land. This view of the Pure Land as an actual realm or place was defended by masters of Pure Land Buddhism like Shandao.

Another interpretation of a Pure Land is that it is non-dual with our world since the whole world is mind-only. The Vimalakīrti Sutra was widely cited by exponents of this non-dual view of the Pure Land, often called "mind-only" Pure Land (wéixīn jìngtǔ 唯心淨土). This was commonly defended by masters of the Chan / Zen school, but was also accepted by some figures in various traditions including in Tiantai, Pure Land, Yogacara, Zen, and Nichiren Buddhism. Another sutra which teaches the view that the pure land is mainly a kind of pure mind or wisdom (i.e. the five wisdoms) is the Buddhabhūmi-sūtra (Scripture on the Buddha Land, Ch: 佛說佛地經, Taishō Tripitaka no. 680).

In the Platform Sutra for example, Huineng states that only the deluded hope to be born in a faraway land in the west, while the wise who know their nature is empty seek the Pure Land by purifying their minds. These two views of the Pure Land led to many debates in Chinese Buddhism.

In a similar fashion, according to the Huayan school patriarch Fazang, the ultimate view of the Buddha's Pure Land (derived from the Avatamsaka sutra) is that it is interfused with all worlds in the multiverse and indeed with all phenomena (dharmas). This view of the Buddha's Pure Land is inconceivable and all pervasive. Since for Fazang, the entire Dharma realm is visible within each particle in the universe, the Pure Land is therefore contained in every phenomena and is non-dual with our world.

Later Chinese thinkers similarly attempted to synthesize the two ideas. Yúnqī Zhūhóng (1535–1615) saw the Pure Land as an actual place which is a useful upaya (skill means) created by the Buddha. Once beings reach this realm, they realize that it is just the Buddha mind, and that the Buddha's wisdom was not ever separate from their own mind. Real sages can see that both ideas are interconnected and thus can affirm both without any conflict. Similarly, Hānshān Déqīng (c. 1546–1623) taught a synthesis of these various views on the nature of the pure land.

Types of pure lands

Tiantai schema

East Asian Buddhist thinkers taught various schemas which outlined different types or levels of the pure lands. One of the most influential of these was that taught in the Tiantai school which outlined four pure lands:

1. The Land of Sages and Commoners (凡聖同居土), a.k.a. Land of Enlightened and Unenlightened Beings. In this realm, all types of beings dwell, including, devas, śrāvakas, and ordinary human persons (manuṣyà).
2. Land of skillful means with remainder (方便有餘土), in this type of land, beings who have rid themselves of unenlightened views and thoughts (見思) are reborn, such as śrāvakas and pratyekabuddhas.
3. The Land of eternal reward and liberation (實報無障礙土), a realm inhabited by bodhisattvas.
4. The Land of Eternally Tranquil Light (常寂光土), this is the Pure Land of the Dharmakāya; true Buddhahood, the realm of the Buddha's eternal nirvana.

Japanese Pure Land

In Japanese Pure land Buddhism meanwhile, a common distinction is between two main lands that Pure Land devotees can be reborn in: the Transformed Land and the Fulfilled Land. Shinran (1173 – 1263), the founder of Jōdo Shinshū, discusses this theory, drawing on the teachings of Shandao. Shinran's schema is as follows:

• The Transformed Land of compassionate means (Jp: 方便化土, Hōben Kedo) - the Saṃbhogakāya pure land which is described in the sutras as having various features (trees, jeweled ponds, etc) and is the land that is created by the power of Amitabha Buddha's past vows. Those who meditate on the Buddha Amitabha with faith, but have not fully abandoned self-power and have not attained shinjin (absolute trust in Amitabha Buddha without any doubt or calculation) will be reborn here. Here they instantly attain the bodhisattva stage of non-retrogression (Skt: avaivartika, Ch: 不退轉), gain a divine body and other qualities. Shinran also seems to equate the Transformed Land with the related concept of the "Borderland" (Jp: 辺地, Henji), a type of birth in which one does not see the Buddha for some time until one has been purified of afflictions. This is also called realm of sloth and pride, the castle of doubt, or the womb palace.
• The Truly Fulfilled Land (真実報土, Shinjitsu Hōdo) - This is the eternal and uncreated original Dharmakaya, i.e. Nirvana, Buddhahood, the ultimate reality which is inconceivable. According to Shinran, those who have attained shinjin attain this land instantly after death, thus bypassing all the bodhisattva stages.

Shin Buddhism follows Shinran's schema of the Pure Land to explain the differing results attained by nembutsu practitioners after death. Shin distinguishes two main aspects of the Pure Land: (1) the Transformed Land, perceptible to ordinary beings and attained by those who practice with partial reliance on self-power; (2) and the Truly Fulfilled Land, which is inconceivable and identified with Buddhahood itself, and realized only by those who attain shinjin. The Transformed Land is also associated with the concept of the "Borderland", where beings still burdened by doubt are born in lotus pods and remain temporarily separated from seeing Amida. Although Shinran proclaims the Fulfilled Land where one instantly attains Buddhahood as the real goal of the eighteenth vow, all provisional transformed lands are still seen as compassionate manifestations of the Original Vow.

Hanshan Deqing

According to Hanshan Deqing (1546–1623), who was a leading Chan monk in Ming China, there are three kinds of Pure Lands (associated with the trikaya, the three bodies of the buddha):

• the Eternal Land of Calm Illumination, also known as the Pure Land of mere-mind. This is the land where the Buddhas and bodhisattvas live.
• the Majestic Land of True Reward, which refers to the Huayan view of a Pure Land that pervades the entire universe and is interfused with every particle and phenomenon in existence.
• the Incomplete Land of Expediency, which is the 'Western paradise" of Sukhavati taught in the Amitabha sutras, and is only one of a myriad of such skillfully manifested Pure Lands in existence. This land is associated with the nirmanakaya.

In Tibetan Buddhism

In Tibetan Buddhism, buddhafields (Skt. buddhakṣetra; Wylie: sangs rgyas kyi zhing) or pure realms (Wyl. dag pa'i zhing) are understood as realms arising due to the intention and aspiration of a buddha or bodhisattva. They are also understood to manifest effortlessly and spontaneously from the Buddha qualities.

Types of buddhafields

In Tibetan Buddhism, it is generally held there are two main types of pure lands or buddhafields:

• The Sambhogakāya buddhafield, which is Akaniṣṭha Ghanavyūha (i.e. the Densely Arrayed Akaniṣṭha, Tib. 'Og min rgyan stug po bkod pa; Skt. Ghanavyūhakaniṣṭha), is only accessible to bodhisattvas on the pure stages (eighth to tenth bhumis). This is because traditionally it is held that the sambhogakāya (co-enjoyment body) cannot be perceived by anyone with afflictive obscurations. Akaniṣṭha is where the cosmic Sambhogakāya, Vairocana Jñanasaghara or Vajradhara, resides. It is also the source out of all Nirmāṇakāya Buddhas and Buddhafields such as Sukhāvati emanate from. Furthermore, it is the supreme buddhafield in which all Buddhas attain Buddhahood.
• Nirmāṇakāya buddhafields - which are many, and include Sukhavati, Abhirati, Zangdokpalri (the field of Padmasambhava) and so forth. The nature of these fields vary, some can be attained by all types of beings, others have certain spiritual attainments as requirement.

All buddhafields are understood as ultimately arising from the Dharmakāya, the foundational aspect of the "triple body" of Buddhahood (trikaya). The Dharmakāya is the basis, ground, or "source" (Tibetan: ཆོས་འབྱུང, Wylie: chos 'byung; Sanskrit: dharmodaya), the true nature of reality, out of which all buddhas and buddhafields arise.

Pure vision

Tibetan Buddhism also holds that this world is also a pure land, since samsara and nirvana are non-dual. Specifically, our world is the pure land of the Sambhoghakaya Vairocana Buddha, as stated in the Avatamsaka sutra and other scriptures. Though our realm is already pure, we cannot see the purity of the world due to our delusion and afflictions (as per the Vimalakirti Sutra). However, on attaining the higher bodhisattva stages, the purified mind will be able to witness the purity of this world, along with the majestic displays of the jeweled ground, divine flowers, and so on. Furthermore, Tibetan Vajrayana deity yoga methods require the yogi to maintain a "pure vision" of this realm as being the pure realm of the deity, along with the visualization of their chosen deity. To fail to do this at all times is a deviation from the tantric practice and the esoteric view taught in the tantras.

As explained by Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche:

From the Vajrayana perspective, however, the understanding of buddha fields is a deeper one. The root of the Vajrayana is "pure vision", or the perception of the perfect purity of all phenomena. To enact this purity of perception, we do not perceive the place where we are now as just an ordinary place; we imagine it to be a celestial buddha field.

Mandala

Mandalas, especially sand mandalas, are 'Pure Lands' and may be understood as Nirmāṇakāya, as are all murti, thangka and sacred tools that have been consecrated, dedicated and the 'deity' (yidam) invoked and requested to reside. Some namkha are Pure Lands. According to Nirmāṇakāya (as tulku) theory, nirmanakaya spontaneously arise due to the intention, aspiration, faith and devotion of the sangha.

In other Chinese religions

Chinese Taoism adopted the idea of heaven realms similar to pure lands from Chinese Buddhism. One popular afterlife in Chinese Taoism is the pure land of eternal Sukha (Chánglè Jìngtǔ, 長樂淨土). It has a similar function to pure lands in Buddhism. This pure land is the realm of Tàiyǐ Zhēnrén also known by the longer title Heavenly Venerable Taiyi Savior from Suffering, the Great Emperor of Azure Radiance (青華大帝太乙救苦天尊). Taiyi, like Amitabha, is also said to provide salvation for all sentient beings in the 10 directions, with a different incarnation for each direction.

Chinese Manichean texts also contain depictions of pure lands.

There are various Pure Land worlds described in various texts of various Chinese folk religions and Chinese new religions.