Lably
Skip to content

Quetzalcoatlus

Genus of azhdarchid pterosaurs from the Late Cretaceous

  • 44 min read
  • 6 chapters
Fossil of Quetzalcoatlus, an extinct pterosaur- Took the photo at Senckenberg Museum of Frankfurt
Ghedoghedo · CC BY-SA 3.0

Related on Lably

Through Type (biology), Scavenger and Invertebrate

Quetzalcoatlus northropi has gained fame as a candidate for the largest flying animal ever discovered, though estimating its size has been difficult due to the fragmentary nature of the only known specimen. While wingspan estimates over the years have ranged from 5.2–25.8 m (17–85 ft), more recent estimates hover around 10–11 m (33–36 ft). Previously, smaller azhdarchid specimens were referred to the species Q. lawsoni, though other researchers have questioned the placement of this species within the genus.

Historical interpretations of the diet of Quetzalcoatlus have ranged from scavenging to skim-feeding like the modern skimmer bird. However, more recent research has found that it most likely hunted small prey on the ground, in a similar way to storks and ground hornbills. This has been dubbed the terrestrial stalking hypothesis and is thought to be a common feeding behavior among large azhdarchids. On the other hand, the disputed second species, Q. lawsoni, appears to have been associated with alkaline lakes, and a diet of small aquatic invertebrates has been suggested. Similarly, while Q. northropi is speculated to have been fairly solitary, Q. lawsoni appears to have been highly gregarious (social). Azhdarchids like Quetzalcoatlus were highly terrestrial by pterosaur standards, though even the largest were nonetheless capable of flight. Based on the work of Mark P. Witton and Michael Habib in 2010, it now seems likely that pterosaurs, especially larger taxa such as Quetzalcoatlus, launched quadrupedally (from a four-legged posture), using the powerful muscles of their forelimbs to propel themselves off the ground and into the air.

Research history and taxonomy

Discovery and naming

The genus Quetzalcoatlus is based on fossils discovered in rocks pertaining to the Late Cretaceous Javelina Formation in Big Bend National Park, Texas. Remains of dinosaurs and other prehistoric life had been found in the area since the beginning of the 20th century. The first Quetzalcoatlus fossils were discovered in 1971 by the graduate student Douglas A. Lawson while conducting field work for his Master's degree project on the paleoecology of the Javelina Formation. This field work was supervised by Wann Langston Jr., an experienced paleontologist who had been doing field work in the region since 1938 and since 1963 led expeditions through his position as curator at the Texas Science and Natural History Museum. The two had first visited the park together in March 1970, with Lawson discovering the first Tyrannosaurus rex fossil from Texas. Returning in 1971, Lawson discovered a 3 ft (0.91 m) bone while investigating an arroyo on the western edge of the park, and returned to Austin with a 1 ft (0.30 m) section of it. He and Langston then identified it as a pterosaur fossil based on its hollow internal structure with thin walls. Returning in November 1971 for further excavations, they were struck by the unprecedented size of the remains compared to known pterosaurs. The initial material consisted of a giant radius and ulna, two fused wristbones known as syncarpals, and the end of the wing finger. Altogether, the material comprised a partial left wing from an individual (specimen number TMM 41450-3) later estimated at over 10 m (33 ft) in wingspan. Lawson described the remains in his 1972 thesis as "Pteranodon gigas", and diagnosed it as being "nearly twice as large as any previously described species of Pteranodon". As a thesis is not recognized as a published work by the International Code for Zoological Nomenclature (ICZN), "Pteranodon gigas" is not a valid name. Further field work at the site was conducted in March 1973, when fragments were found alongside a long and delicate bone connected to an apparently larger element. This fossil was left in the ground until April 1974, when they fully excavated the larger element, a humerus. Due to the close association of discovered remains, Langston felt confident there was nothing more to be found at the site. Several later excavations of the site have indeed been unsuccessful.

Lawson announced his discovery in the journal Science in March 1975, with a depiction of the animal's size compared to a large aircraft and a Pteranodon gracing the cover of the issue. Lawson wrote that it was "without doubt the largest flying animal presently known". He illustrated and briefly described the remains known at the time, but did not offer a name and indicated that a more extensive description was in preparation that would diagnose the species. In May, he submitted to the journal a short response to his original paper considering how such an enormous animal could have flown. Within the paper, he briefly established the name Quetzalcoatlus northropi, but still did not provide a diagnosis or a more detailed description, which would later cause nomenclatural problems. Though not specified in the original publication, Lawson named the genus after the Aztec feathered serpent god Quetzalcōātl, while the specific name honors John Knudsen Northrop, the founder of Northrop Corporation, who drove the development of large tailless Northrop YB-49 aircraft designs resembling Quetzalcoatlus. The discovery of the giant pterosaur left a strong impression on both the scientific community and the general public, and was reported on throughout the world. It was featured in Time Magazine and appeared on the cover of Scientific American in 1981 alongside an article on pterosaurs by Langston. The species would become referenced by over 500 scientific publications, with Quetzalcoatlus northropi becoming the single most cited pterosaur species and Quetzalcoatlus the fourth most cited pterosaur genus after Pteranodon, Rhamphorhynchus, and Pterodactylus, much older genera with many more species than Quetzalcoatlus.

Prior to the announcement of the discovery, Langston had returned to Big Bend with a group of fossil preparators in February 1973, primarily aiming to excavate bones of the dinosaur Alamosaurus. One of the preparators, a young man named Bill Amaral who went on to be a respected field worker, had been skipping his lunches to conduct additional explorations of the area. He came across some additional fragments of pterosaur bone on a different portion of the ridge, around 50 kilometers away from the original site. Two more new sites quickly followed nearby, producing many fragments which the crew figured could be fit back together, in addition to a complete carpal and intact wing bone. Langston noted in his field notes that none of these bones suggested animals as large as Lawson's original specimen. Further remains came from Amaral's first site in April 1974, after Lawson's site had been exhausted; a long neck vertebra and a pair of jawbones appeared. Associated structures were initially hoped to represent filamentous pycnofibres, but were later confirmed to be conifer needles. Near the end of the 1974 season, Langston stumbled over a much more complete pterosaur skeleton; it consisted of a wing, multiple vertebrae, a femur and multiple other long bones. They lacked time to fully excavate it, leaving it in the ground until the next field season. This area, where many smaller specimens began to emerge, came to be known as Pterodactyl Ridge. Two of the smaller individuals were reported in the first 1975 paper by Lawson, presumed to belong to the same species, though Langston would begin to question the idea they belonged to Q. northropi by the early 1980s. Excavations continued in 1976, and eight new specimens emerged in 1977; in 1979, despite complications due to losing the field notes from 1977, Langston discovered another new site that would produce an additional ten specimens. Most importantly, a humerus of the smaller animal was finally found, which Langston considered of great importance to understanding Quetzalcoatlus. Several further new localities followed in 1980, but 1981 proved less successful and Langston began to suspect the ridge may have been mostly depleted of pterosaur fossils. There was similarly little success in 1982, and visits during 1983 and 1985 proved to provide the last substantive discoveries of Quetzalcoatlus fossils. Langston returned in 1989, 1991, 1992, and 1996, but only found isolated bones and fragments. Eventually a handful of additional specimens were discovered by former student Thomas Lehman. A visit to Lawson's initial site during 1991 showed that all traces of excavation had by now eroded away. Langston would visit Big Bend for the last time in 1999, having concluded the pterosaur expeditions to focus on the excavation of two skulls of Deinosuchus, another famous fossil of the area.

Later research

The expected further description implicated by Lawson never came. For the next 50 years, the material would remain under incomplete study, and few concrete anatomical details were documented within the literature. Much confusion surrounded the smaller individuals from Pterodactyl Ridge. In a 1981 article on pterosaurs, Langston expressed reservations whether they were truly the same species as the immense Q. northropi. In the meantime, Langston focused on the animal's publicity. He worked on a life-sized gliding replica of Quetzalcoatlus northropi with aeronautical engineer Paul MacCready between 1981 and 1985, promoting it in a dedicated IMAX film. The model was created to understand the flight of the animal — prior to Lawson's discovery such a large flier wasn't thought possible, and the subject remained controversial at the time. Furthermore, the model was intended to allow people to experience the animal in a more dynamic manner than a mere static display or film. Around this time he also created a skeletal mount of the genus that was exhibited at the Texas Memorial Museum.

The next scientific effort of note was a 1996 paper by Langston and pterosaur specialist Alexander Kellner. By this time, Langston was confident the smaller animals were a separate species. A full publication establishing such a species was still in preparation at the time, but due to the importance of the skull material for the understanding of azhdarchid anatomy, the skull anatomy was published first. In this publication, the animal was referred to as Quetzalcoatlus sp., a placeholder designation for material not assigned to any particularly valid species. Once again, the planned further publication failed to materialize for decades, and Quetzalcoatlus sp. remained in limbo. A publication on the bioaeromechanics of the genus was also planned by Langston and James Cunningham, but this failed to materialize and the partially completed manuscript later became lost. Ultimately, a comprehensive publication on Quetzalcoatlus sp. would not appear before Langston's death in 2013. By this point he had produced many notes and individual descriptions, but had not begun writing any formal manuscript that could be published.

In 2021, a comprehensive description of the genus was finally published, the 19th entry in the Memoir series of special publications by the Society of Vertebrate Paleontology in the Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. It consisted of five studies published together. Kevin Padian was the primary organizer of the project. A paper on the history of discoveries in Big Bend National Park was authored by Matthew J. Brown, Chris Sagebiel, and Brian Andres. It focused on curating a comprehensive list of specimens belonging to each species to Quetzalcoatlus and the locality information of each within Big Bend. Thomas Lehman contributed a study on the paleonvironment that Quetzalcoatlus would have resided within, based upon work he had begun with Langston as early as 1993. Brian Andres published a study on the morphology and taxonomy of the genus, established species Quetzalcoatlus lawsoni for the smaller animal that had gone for decades without a name. The specific name honoured Lawson, who discovered Quetzalcoatlus. Despite not contributing directly to the written manuscript, the authors of the memoir and Langston's family agreed that he posthumously be considered a co-author due the basis of the work in the decades of research he dedicates to the subject. Also authored by Andres was a phylogenetic study of Quetzacoatlus and its relationships within Pterosauria, with a focus on the persistence of many lineages into the Late Cretaceous contra classical interpretations of Quetzalcoatlus as the last of a dying lineage. Finally, a study on the functional morphology of the genus was authored by Padian, James Cunningham, and John Conway (who contributed scientific illustrations and cover art to the Memoir), with Langston once again considered a posthumous co-author due to his foundational work on the subject. Brown and Padian prefaced the Memoir, and once again emphasized their gratitude to Langston for his decades of work on the animal leading up to the publication.

Taxonomy and material

Though the name Quetzalcoatlus was introduced in 1975, the lack of a formal description complicated its validity for several decades. The oldest name for the species is "Pteranodon gigas", from Lawson's 1973 thesis. However, the International Code of Zoological Nomenclature (ICZN) does not consider a thesis to be a formal publication capable of establishing of a taxon, and the name has not been used since. Regarding the genus Quetzalcoatlus and species Q. northropi, the name being established in a separate publication than the anatomical diagnosis also failed ICZN standards. As such, it was argued that the name was a nomen nudum, an intended but invalid scientific name, though some authors argued the second publication referencing the initial description was sufficient. The species received a diagnosis in a 1991 paper by Lev Nessov, but no action was taken to formalize the name. Furthermore, a study by Mark Witton and colleagues in 2010 doubted whether Quetzalcoatlus could be validly diagnosed at all. They noted that the bones preserved in the holotype of Q. northropi were not typically considered to be taxonomically informative between close relatives, and that they appeared extremely similar to those of other giant azhdarchids such as the Romanian azhdarchid Hatzegopteryx. Both of these issues were settled in the 2021 paper, whose rediagnosis affirmed Quetzalcoatlus as distinct. The authors agreed that the original paper did not constitute a valid establishment of the name. The authors noted their publication could serve as the a basis for the name, but did not wish to change the previously presumed authorship of the name. Thus, they submitted an application for the ICZN in 2017 to make an exception to the requirements, and had Lawson's second 1975 paper to be declared as the valid authority of the genus and species. The approval of this ICZN petition on August 30, 2019, conserved and formalized the binomen Quetzalcoatlus northropi as the type species.

The name-bearing type specimen of Q. northropi is TMM 41450-3, a partial wing. It includes a humerus, radius, ulna, wrist bones, finger bones, and many elements of the elongate wing finger, in addition to thousands of unidentifiable fragments. It is from the uppermost rocks of the Javelina Formation, making it one of the youngest pterosaur specimens known. Only a single other specimen can confidently be assigned to the same species, a left ulna designated TMM 44036-1 known from the Black Peaks Formation, around three quarters the size of the type specimen and sharing distinctive anatomy. Four other specimens share a similarly giant size, but cannot be definitively assigned to Q. northropi in lack of overlapping material or distinguishing anatomical regions. TMM 41047-1 and TMM 41398-3, are both partial femurs, the former twice the size of that seen in Q. lawsoni. Their anatomy indicates they belonged to the same species, and is distinct from that of Q. lawsoni. Part of a wing finger, TMM 41398-4, is also of the correct size to belong to Q. northropi but does not preserve the essential anatomy to confirm its identity. This specimen and the smaller femur were the first two specimens Lawson discovered, prior to uncovering the type specimen. Finally, one of the oldest pterosaur specimens in Big Bend is a giant cervical vertebra not matching that of smaller species from the formation. While conventional pterosaur research would assign all of these to Q. northropi, the 2021 redescription preferred to be cautious and merely assigned them to Q. cf. northropi, indicating uncertainty.

The assignment of remains to Q. lawsoni has proved more simplistic; a large quantity of similar remains were found together in nearby sites, 50 km from the Q. northropi locality. In total, 305 different fossil elements from 214 specimens are known, all of which are considered consistent with assignment to the same species. This is the most remains assigned to any singular species of pterosaur. The vast majority of the dozens of specimens are disarticulated individual bones. A few individual animals are, however, represented by associated remains; identification of these individuals was complicated by each bone being catalogued under a separate number, which was revised as part of the 2021 study. The most complete specimen is TMM 41961-1, which possesses the most complete skull as well as several neck vertebrae, much of both wings, femurs, tibiotarsi, two metatarsals, and one of the toe bones. It was one of the original specimens described by Langston in 1975, and in accordance with Langston's wishes and its completeness was designated as the type specimen. Two less complete specimens, TMM 42180-14 and TMM 42161-1, were also preserved in partial articulation, the former mostly composed of limb and neck bones while the latter consists of neck and skull bones. Beyond this, identification of individual specimens is difficult. Two other specimens are more loosely associated, and others may have belonged to a single individual but are too weathered to identify with confidence. In some cases two or three neck vertebrae were found in presumed association, and similar loose associations of one or two limbs bones are seen in several cases. Taken together, nearly the entirely skeleton is represented, with the exception of some of the back of the skull. Eight different specimens preserve various portions of the skull, together allowing for a rather complete picture (excepting a portion of the back of the skull), and similarly the entire mandible is represented when cross-referencing four specimens. All nine neck vertebrae are known, and most torso vertebrae are known through the preservation of the notarium and synsacrum, structures consisting of several fused vertebrae in ornithocheiroid pterosaurs; it is unknown how many unfused vertebrae may have existed between these structures. Every single bone in the arm is known from at least one complete specimen, and the hindlimbs and pelvis are also more or less all present, though the femur and pelvis suffer from poor preservation. In 2025, Quetzalcoatlus was suggested to be polyphyletic with Quetzalcoatlus lawsoni not being sister to Quetzalcoatlus northropi.

Other assigned and reclassified material

Though most pterosaur remains from Big Bend have been assigned to Quetzalcoatlus, some other material exists. Most prominent amongst these is a specimen discovered around 380 metres (1,250 ft) north of the Pterodactyl Ridge localities, designated as TMM 42489-2 and compromising a partial skull and jaws as well as five articulated neck vertebrae. It was immediately noted for its distinct shorted-jawed anatomy compared to what had come to be expected from Q. lawsoni specimens. Despite this distinctiveness, it was assigned to as a separate Quetzalcoatlus sp. in a 1991 book by Langston. As early as 1996, however, this was revised with recognition it was certainly a new genus informally known as the "short-faced pterosaur". It was formally named in the 2021 paper alongside Q. lawsoni, as the genus Wellnhopterus. In addition to this specimen, several indeterminate azhdarchid remains and some remains too fragmentary to assign beyond Pterosauria are known from Big Bend. Some of these represent smaller animals than the uniformly sized Q. lawsoni remains. Whether any of these remains represented separate animals from Quetzalcoatlus cannot be determined.

Several specimens from across Late Cretaceous North America were historically assigned to Quetzalcoatlus. In 1982 a femur from the Campanian aged Dinosaur Park Formation of Alberta, Canada was assigned to the genus by Philip J. Currie and Dale Russell. Currie later described further remains from Dinosaur Park in a 2005 book, noting their morphological similarity to Quetzalcoatlus but expressing caution against referral to the genus. In 2019, however, all azhdarchid remains from the formation were revised as distinct from Quetzalcoatlus and named as the new genus Cryodrakon. A humerus from the Two Medicine Formation in Montana was also provisionally assigned to the genus; it was considered an indeterminate azhdarchid or a specimen of Montanazhdarcho by subsequent studies. A neck vertebra from the Hell Creek Formation, also from Montana but dating to the Maastrichtian, was discovered in 2002 and initially assigned in 2006 to Quetzalcoatlus. The 2021 paper merely considered it an azhdarchiform specimen of uncertain affinities, but the 2025 study named it as the holotype of a distinct genus Infernodrakon.

Another neck vertebra, discovered in the similarly aged Lance Formation in Wyoming and first described in 1964, was later assigned to Quetzalcoatlus by Brent H. Breithaupt in 1982; later studies assigned it to Azhdarcho or an indeterminate azhdarchid or azhdarchiform. The 2025 Infernodrakon study found it to be distinguishable from that taxon, but anatomically compatible with Q. lawsoni; when tested in a phylogenetic analysis, they found it to form a polytomy with Q. lawsoni, Q. northropi, and a Moroccan specimen. Therefore, they considered it plausible it belonged to a small Q. lawsoni individual, but decided to merely make a tentative referral to Quetzalcoatlus at the genus level due to the incomplete nature of the specimen. The Moroccan specimen, from the Ouled Abdoun Basin (Maastrichtian), is designated as FSAC-OB 14 and was assigned to aff. Quetzalcoatlus by a 2018 study. This indicates it is considered unlikely to belong to the genus but bears extreme anatomical similarity to it.

Sign in to keep reading

5 more chapters are free with a Lably account.

More in Animals